Post New Topic

SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

sweetadeline Posted:

SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

C'mon people! I rely on you for your comments on important issues!

So, J.D. Huh. As noted last week, the singer who most resembles the dearly departed Michael Hutchence -- in looks, moves, voice, and perhaps even attitude. I think the band went with him due to the familiar yet perhaps unrecognized strains of Hutchenceness. Hutchenceosity, if you will.

J.D. did get better as the show went on, but I really thought Marty had the competition in the bag. AND I thought that Marty's final performance with the band was better, too. Marty could become the Clay Aiken figure here... the guy who does better even though he came in second. As long as he doesn't start crooning Aikenesque power ballads, I'm OK with that.

Anyhoo, J.D.'s fine, and I found his reaction to his win kinda sorta touching. OK, maybe I felt a wee bit misty-eyed.

Now that the show is over, I remember why I was boycotting it: I didn't actually want to see INXS with a new singer. That'll teach me for getting sucked into the Reality Show Vortex!

Your thoughts?
janwinterbridejoy Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

i knew that jd was going to win he sounds the most like the old singer . i think they made a good choice. marty has a lot of talent and will be sucessful without inxs i think even more the jd because he wont have to compete with ghosts

103005FallBride Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

JD was a better fit for INXS because of the similarities like you both said.

LOVE MARTY!!! I was so excited for what INXS asked...and what Dave Navarro said.

Anyone in line for tix when they go on sale?!
stephanief Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

I think JD was more versatile than Marty, but I liked them both. I think they made a good choice.

Loved the show !!!!
12-3Princess Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

wasn't anyone as shocked as me that Mig didn't win? I totally thought he was gonna win... since day 1!

sweetadeline Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?


Posted by 12-3Princess

wasn't anyone as shocked as me that Mig didn't win? I totally thought he was gonna win... since day 1!



At first, I thought that he might win because of the Australian fans and the fact that the band might've wanted another Australian guy. As the show went on, though, I thought that he might be too 'show tune' for INXS.

As for getting tickets? Maybeeeeee...
oakslady Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

i'd go see marty in concert --- as for jd i never liked him - marty should have taken it - but i agree he will do much better as a solo
The Original 2nd-time-around Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?


Posted by 103005FallBride

JD was a better fit for INXS because of the similarities like you both said.

LOVE MARTY!!! I was so excited for what INXS asked...and what Dave Navarro said.

Anyone in line for tix when they go on sale?!



I totally agree, and I'll be in line
Pookiesangel Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?


Posted by The Original 2nd-time-around


Posted by 103005FallBride

JD was a better fit for INXS because of the similarities like you both said.

LOVE MARTY!!! I was so excited for what INXS asked...and what Dave Navarro said.

Anyone in line for tix when they go on sale?!



I totally agree, and I'll be in line



I second that! I like JD from early on, and was happy to see him win, I was sad Mig was elimated early on, he was my second favorite, I just never really dug Marty, he is talented and I'm sure he will do well
AmyKay Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

Glad Marty didn't win! I liked him, I loved 'Trees' but he is not for INXS.

I really liked Suzy!!!
JD is a really good Fit!
nferrandi Posted:

Re: SPOILER: What? No Rock Star INXS thread?

My friend and I were obsessed with that show! I loved Marty and she loved JD. As for Mig, I loved his look, but for some reason I couldn't really get into him. As much as I like Marty, I think JD was the right choice for INXS.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.