Tavern on the Green or Gotham Hall - New Bride Searching for Everything

Anyone have any feedback on Tavern on The Green or Gotham Hall???? We are going to look at these places first and just wanted to know if anyone has been to either for an event.
Thanks!!!

I've been to Tavern for dinner only, but a friend of mine has gone there for a wedding and said it wasn't worth what it cost the b&g. She said that the service was terrible.

Thanks for the replys so far. I really appreciate it. I'm stressing already! My FH really wants to get married in Manhattan, so our search will start there. THX again!!

Depending on your budget, there are some great venues. I don't know what your style is... but try:

Tribeca Rooftop (they are catered by the same people as Lands End, etc.) They are about $200-$250/person for a Saturday night, and they have a high minimum. http://www.tribec.com/

I LOVED this place, but its definitely an acquired taste, I think. But the views are fantastic:
The Foundry
http://www.thefoundry.info/images.html
They have a $6,000 site rental fee, and then you have to get catering, tables, etc. But its a beautiful place.

Also, look into the Rainbow Room. I went to a wedding there, and it was gorgeous. I've heard rumors though that its about $400-$500/person for a Sat night. Not sure if thats true.

Finally - Abigail Kirsch - the Lighthouse at Chelsea Piers is BEAUTIFUL. http://www.abigailkirsch.com/lh.html Again, more than $200/person for a Sat night. But these guys do a GREAT job. One of my coworkers was married here and said the service is impeccable.

Just keep in mind that for a NYC wedding you are looking at AT LEAST $200/head. Good luck! FM if you have questions. I started out my search by looking at NYC venues too, so I know quite a bit of them!

Thank you all soo much!
We are going to Tribeca Rooftop this afternoon, so I'll post any updates, also Tavern today. I just love being on vacation this week and running all over the place anyway
I'll def check out the other suggestions.... Thanks again! Have a great day everyone!