Post New Topic

The masks are here!!!!!

coldasice217 Posted:

The masks are here!!!!!

But not without controversy, naturally lol.

After much strife over these masks, they FINALLY arrived today, and all day at work I was anxiously waiting to come home to see them.

So I open up the package, and my mask and the favor sized masks for the cake table are GORGEOUS. I couldn't be happier with the way they came out, they're beyond cool. I wasn't aware that the favor sized ones come on sticks, so I'll have to get white florist foam blocks to stick them in, but other than that, no hidden surprises and awesome quality.









And then I opened up FH's mask, and got SO upset. The gold detailing is raised on the mask, and painted over the raised lines. Same as mine. Only this one was ridiculously sloppy. The paint bled off the raised details on to the background of the mask, and it looks like the painter didn't have a steady hand at all. Either it was shellacked before the gold was dry, or everything was still wet when it was packed, because it's just all smudged and messy looking. Even the white inside the left eyebrow is showing some of the black from underneath, like each layer wasn't dried before the next step was painted. It's a little hard to tell in the pics, but can you see the difference between the quality of the two full sized masks?









I already sent an email to the owner informing her that I wasn't happy with this one mask, explained what it looked like, and asked what can be done about it. Their policy is that they will return or exchange but it will take 4 weeks, and I'd have to send it back first. To say that I don't trust doing that is the understatement of the year. I would be willing to send this mask back after I received a new one, because I don't want this one, it's really not up to quality standards, but I think they'd trust me to do that just as much as I'd trust them to actually send a new one once I send this back.

This is all assuming I ACTUALLY get a reply to the email. What do you think I should do? Try to exchange it for a new one, or just s/uck it up and be done with this whole ordeal with them? This has been my most annoying and frustrating vendor experience so far, and I should probably just deal with it and cut my loss. But the mask was $58 dollars, not cheap, and I don't feel that one in this condition is worth that. The others are all so beautiful, it's a real shame.
Gracie821 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

I would not just deal with it, I would demand that they replace it. Hopefully everything works out!

allegracristina Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

Wow they look awesome!! I'm so so glad this ended up working out for you!! I honestly can't tell from the pics what the quality of his mask is like...I would definitely wait to see what the owner says about fixing it for you. Be polite, but you deserve to be happy for that price, on a handmade custom item.

Celeste617 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

They look beautiful! Hey, if the mask was under $10 I'd say screw it, but that's a lot of money you spent. I would expect that it would be in better condition (I can't really see all the mistakes, but I trust you!)

coldasice217 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!


Posted by Celeste617

They look beautiful! Hey, if the mask was under $10 I'd say screw it, but that's a lot of money you spent. I would expect that it would be in better condition (I can't really see all the mistakes, but I trust you!)



In the pics of FH's mask, the highlighted parts of the gold where the flash is reflecting off is the raised part. That's the only part that should have the paint on it...but you can kinda see how there's fuzzy gold around that sharper part right? That's where it's actually bled on to the background of the mask. The camera wasn't in great focus so really hard to see in pics.

FH will be here in a few minutes, and will inspect, and I can't WAIT to hear him flip out about it
JennyAPH Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

ali they look great..

sorry you are upset with the one mask. I would wait to see what the owner says before you make up your mind.. but IMO if you can return it i would, you spent alot of money on it and they should be good quality!
MrsDtoBe09 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

Wow those are beautiful! Where did you order them from?

coldasice217 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!


Posted by MrsDtoBe09

Wow those are beautiful! Where did you order them from?



I ordered them from Karnevalmasque.com. I would recommend them only if you are super patient and do not get uncomfortable if your emails and phone calls go unreturned. The work is for the most part excellent with the exception of the detailing on the one piece here, but for me I like a little more responsiveness, since I do it myself for a living with sales and marketing, you know?
MrsDtoBe09 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

Thanks! I'm a teacher so I'd like to think I'm incredibly patient! I'll definitely check them out...I've ordered from tons of mask places already and the quality has been super cheap!
geegee827 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

I think they look beautiful, Ali! It's really hard to tell from the picture about the quality of FH's mask. You definitely deserve 100% customer satisfaction though. Let us know if you get a response to your email.

MrsGRod09 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

All the masks look gorgeous!! If your not happy then definitely ask for a replacement.

coldasice217 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

***UPDATE***

I got a response and was basically told that it is not smudged, but intentionally looks like that because it's an 'antique' process used on the leafing. I countered and asked if it was a different process than my mask, because my leafing is more crisp. In either event, no offer was made to do anything about an exchange, etc. because it is not damaged, but rather SUPPOSED to look like that.

I guess it's not a super big deal, but I do wish that the picture was a little more clear on their website, because had FH seen that the detailing had the 'antiqued' effect I know he wouldn't have picked that one.
gina409 Posted:

Re: The masks are here!!!!!

they look great!!!!!! i hope they can fix it for you so its what u want..u should not have to settle

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.