ty!

Comparison of the lombardis - Long Island Weddings

I haven't been to weddings at either, but keep in mind that you got married in 2012 (per your profile) and prices go up every year. Not sure when you booked, but even if you booked in 2011, that's 3 years ago and figure the price goes up $5pp maybe. Also the Sound charges an additional $10pp 'waterview fee,' so that might be jacking up the price even more. I'd be curious in what Villa charges per head nowadays and comparing that with Sound's pricing!

Comparison of the lombardis - Long Island Weddings

I think $95 is actually a really good price for Lombardi's on the Sound. We were quoted $110 per person before tax/gratuities for a Saturday night and that was from 2012.
The thing is that Villa's is totally different from the ones on the sound or the bay so even if she got a great price she has to decide what she wants. I went to a wedding at Villas in December 2012 and I thought it was ok, the food wasn't that great. Also, she was the only wedding at her time but there also was a company party, a baby shower and a christening party all going on in the same building.