We didnt like our RH bakery, Buttercooky, and we liked the TASTE of Dortino's, but the service was awful. The woman barely paid any attention to us and she just kept saying 'yes yes' to everything even though it was clear she didnt understand what I was trying to say. PLUS they were a good 50% higher, all things being equal. So we want to try two more places. Where would you recommend? Taste is first important, design skill is second, price is important, but not the most important. Thanks!
cj21512
Posted:
Member since
Wedding Cake Suggestions!
Check out Audrey's in Sayville and The Rolling Pin in Bayshore or Setauket
sillylily
Posted:
Member since
Wedding Cake Suggestions!
Wow what flavors did u try at Buttercooky? We tried like 6 bakeries and stuck with them. People seem to like rolling pin.
I'd say try Black Forest Bakery!!! We get all of my occasion cakes from there and they are ALWAYS delicious! They are actually the preferred vendor for my venue so it makes me super happy :)
GoingToBoyle
Posted:
Member since
Re: Wedding Cake Suggestions!
Posted by cj21512
Check out Audrey's in Sayville and The Rolling Pin in Bayshore or Setauket
Definitely check out Audrey's!
jsh109
Posted:
Member since
Wedding Cake Suggestions!
Leonetti's in Greenvale!!
cets1290
Posted:
Member since
Wedding Cake Suggestions!
The milleridge bakery inside the milleridge village- delicious and when you do your cake tasting they give you THREE nine inch round cakes to bring home with you- you can have a cake tasting party with your entire BP!
amanda1126
Posted:
Member since
Wedding Cake Suggestions!
The Rolling Pin is great!
JenL
Posted:
Member since
Wedding Cake Suggestions!
Hated Rolling Pin. Try Alpine Bakery.
Karin
Posted:
Member since
Wedding Cake Suggestions!
These are all good suggestions. The thing about Buttercooky was more FH's perception than mine. They all seem to be about the same, but FH is obsessed with the cake! LOL
