Where can I buy paper for programs and menus?

I went to Michael's, Papyrus, and AC Moore and wasn't too impressed with the selections there.

Can you recommend other places? Internet sites?

Where did/are you buying yours?

Try paperandmore.com - they will cut it for you at an extra charge, but depending on how much you need cut (if at all) it may be worth it.
Good Luck!

just left staples.. a great selection

OMG this has been my headache all weekend, i am in the process of doing menu's for e-party and its been a pain. I also went to michaels and was not impressed. I am going to paper stores in the city this week. Here are the places I am checking out: Sam Flax, Katie's paperie, Cranes, Paper presentation.

I do have to agree with staples, i was out today and walked by a staples and decided to stop and look. They did have a real nice selection, they have a wedding stationary section with great options and they have plain colored card stocks too depending on what you want, they also had sticky paper if you want to use vellum and you can just stick it on top of the other paper, it was great.