Where to get inexpensive dyeable shoes??

A few places you can try:

Sandy's Shoes in Massapequa
Shoe Boutique in Westbury
Dying for You in Lindenhurst
Casa Di Mario in Patchogue
DSW in Westbury

And I've heard Craft Shoes is really good but I don't know where it is.

Payless is the cheapest I think
DSW
HAzels in Bayside does a really good job

craft shoes in commack
estelles in melville
and payless

I found the help at Sandy's in Massapequa super, super helpful .. but didn't care for the service at Crafty Shoes .. basically .. because they didn't help, at all .. made me feel very unwelcomed.

And yes .. the prices at Sandy's were very reasonable.