which makeup job looks better?

I've already asked my girls but thought I'd ask on here to get opinions also since everyone is always so helpful

which makeup look is better? in the Donna album or the Bre album? I should add I'm on a hardcore diet so from May (when Donna pics were taken) and Oct (Bre pics) that's why my face looks skinnier. my aunt who saw them was like how did she change your face shape? lol.