which slip?

I originally was planning on buying my slip from my salon but I just found out they charge $125 ! So I was looking on Ebay and there seems to be one seller who has a huge selection. I am unsure if I should get an extra full or a super full. I am wearing the private label 1226 gown and have tried it on with a medium A line slip but it really wasn't as poofy as I had wanted. When I went last week to try on my gown after it arrived the woman suggested adding a few pieces of crinoline along the bottom to poof it out (for $20 a piece) with the medium A line slip, but if I get a poofier slip that may not have to be done.I am so not sure on what to do. Do I order one on Ebay and if so which one? Or suck up the price difference and proceed on my salon's suggestions?

I got mine from e-bay, super full one. When I got it, it really looked like the State Puff Marshmallow Man was standing in my computer room . I have to say it was perfect with the dress though when I tried it on. The dress weighed it down a lot so don't worry about it being too much. Your seamstress can also remove some of the material inside if it does turn out to be too much.

be careful, though.

I bought a slip on ebay, and it was really nice.... until I tried it on with the gown.

too puffy! It actaully started to pull the box pleats apart a bit... (my dress is likely supposed to be less puffy than yours )

now I need another one. I don't even know what to do with this one... it's brand new and will end up being un-used...