LIWeddings.com
Post New Topic

Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

vickalina Posted:

Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

It is a tie between Jason and Andy!!!

julybride444 Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

I like Mike Mussina
nycchic_24 Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Mussina is my baby but so is Petitte.

But my one and only will always and forever be TINO MARTINEZ! He is the hottest ever!!!!

I miss him
prncssrachel Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

I don't know, I really think I have to say Giambi. Grrrrrr.
prncssrachel Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Wow, I just noticed no Jeter on your poll. Intersting. If I could put his cute little buns on Giambi, we'd have perfection
joeslauren Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

not a yankee fan (met fan here!), but since dh is.. i happened to get to know them.. more for their looks than their skill. pettite! what a hottie!
Stacey1403 Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Noreen I was so upset when they traded Tino So now I have to say Clemens
Dani00518 Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

I know he is not on your poll but I'm sorry to say that Jeter is the only man for me.........SHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
don't tell my DH....he thinks he is the only man for me
The Original 2nd-time-around Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Mussina and JETER!!!!

sept20yay Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

I love petitte! but felt that no one else thought he was cute. there is just something about him though!!!!

Jenn524 Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Without Jeter on that list, I have to go with Clemens. There's just something about his Texan cowboy look that I love. I love Andy too, but sometimes I don't find him too attractive.

prncssrachel Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

I like Andy as well, but he reminds me of a great dane. you know, those big dogs.

Wendy Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Has to be Jeter even though he isn't on your list. Other than that I would have to say Clemens!

prncssrachel Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

We had a very in depth conversation about Jeter's tush at Corinne7477's bachelorette party and I decided that if I ever get the chance to squeeze Jeter's cheeks, JT will just have to deal with it
Boop2704 Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Aaron Boone!! I know he doesn't look like a hottie on TV. But, when I saw him in person, whew, he was a cutie!!
prncssrachel Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Ok, I retract my votes! I only think they're hot when they're winning!
swags1016 Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Since my Mother thinks that Frankie looks like Petitte with a smaller nose he gets my vote!!!

jillnbrad Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Why isn't Derek Jeter on this list??????????????????????????? He's my vote
Teri Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Andy has been my hottie since he joined the Yankees in '95
vickalina Posted:

Re: Who do you think is the most handsome Yankee?

Posted by prncssrachel

Ok, I retract my votes! I only think they're hot when they're winning!


LOL....I am with you on that one!!!

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.