LIWeddings.com
Post New Topic

Who got kicked of American Idol?

ZuzusPetals Posted:

Who got kicked of American Idol?

I missed it

bride2b24 Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

me too! im so upset.......

N.Y.bride Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Patrick Hall - which I didnt agree with IMO It should have been Bucky

Bobby Bennet - terrible IMO

Stevie Scott - terrible IMO

Becky O'Donohue - not so good IMO

I agreed with 3/4
ZuzusPetals Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Posted by N.Y.bride

Patrick Hall - I dont agree with that decision either - I thought he was good and there are people there that I think are far less talented than him

Bobby Bennet - thank goodness ... so bad!

Stevie Scott - agree with you too - she was terrible

Becky O'Donohue - I agree she wasnt my fav.

I agreed with 3/4
ZuzusPetals Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Posted by ZuzusPetals



Patrick Hall - I dont agree with that decision either - I thought he was good and there are people there that I think are far less talented than him

Bobby Bennet - thank goodness ... so bad!

Stevie Scott - agree with you too - she was terrible

Becky O'Donohue - I agree she wasnt my fav.

I agreed with 3/4
ZuzusPetals Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

thanks for answering by the way
Hamptonsbride06 Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Did Becky get voted off, or was she let go because of her topless photos?

N.Y.bride Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

voted off. She was not a great singer IMO, but she shoudl definately model! She is beautiful.

ZuzusPetals Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

i didnt even know she had a topless photo scandal .. she is beautiful but not the best singer

july06bride Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

do you think they could have rigged it so becky was kicked off tonight...because although she wasnt the best, she wasnt the worst by far and with the topless photos I was thinking it could be that and not actually the singing. I dont know, but she should model!

Hamptonsbride06 Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

She had a spread with her sister in Maxim..and they let that slide, but more recently it came out that she had a topless spread as well, and they dont go for that on American Idol...maybe they did rig it..but I think American Idol would want all the publicity

NinaChris07 Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

I thought Patrick was amazing.... Definitely didn't deserve to be kicked off...

futuremrsGafforio Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

I thought Patrick was great as well, but I agreed with the other singers who got kicked off......

N.Y.bride Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Posted by july06bride

do you think they could have rigged it so becky was kicked off tonight...because although she wasnt the best, she wasnt the worst by far and with the topless photos I was thinking it could be that and not actually the singing. I dont know, but she should model!


I honestly thought they voted off the 2 worst girls. The song was sooo karaoke. Who do you think should have been booted?
Beth1210 Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Posted by ZuzusPetals

i didnt even know she had a topless photo scandal .. she is beautiful but not the best singer


neither did I but- how long do you think until her and her sister are in Playboy?
N.Y.bride Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Posted by Beth1210

Posted by ZuzusPetals

i didnt even know she had a topless photo scandal .. she is beautiful but not the best singer


neither did I but- how long do you think until her and her sister are in Playboy?


Oh not very long at all.
LaurenluvsTJ Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Becky was terrible, she deserved to be voted off. Same with Bobby Bennett - ugh I cringe thinking of him singing Copacabana.
I thought Patrick was good. I didn't hear him sing on Wed. night, but I thought he was great last night, that guy who sang shout should have been voted off.
Stevie was ok, I think there were others who were worse. Was she the one who is a trained opera singer?
Beth1210 Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

which one was Patrick?

LaurenluvsTJ Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

Patrick- don't remember what he sang though/
Beth1210 Posted:

Re: Who got kicked of American Idol?

thanks!

this is my first season watching- and I am hooked

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.