WHY WON'T THE HOBBITT GET VOTED OFF AMERICAN IDOL??!

---

Posted by steph4777

---

Posted by Danielle&Scott

Camille was horrible. She was my first for bottom 3.

JPL was horrible too. I hope they say goodbye to the Hobbit. He was my second choice for bottom 3.

John Stevens was horrible. He was my third choice for bottom 3. It seems he can only sing songs a certian type of way, and he takes the safe route when it is a hard type of music to sing.

Amy Adams was really good.
Diana Degarmo was so so...Her outfit was horrible.

Latoya has the voice of an Angel. The extensions in her hair were horrible though, I have to agree with the judges.

Fantasia was really good...Its funny how she pronounces her 'S''s though.....Instead of Something, she says Shomething for example lol

George...Kicked butt....He was doing his little bouncy dance....He was excellent.

Jennifer was ok...She just annoys me for some reason.

Jasmine's voice wasnt that great tonight...I have seen her do better in other performances...

---

Good recap!

---

Thanks, i try

Last night's episode was pretty terrible until the end. I just want to give George a hug! And I love Fantasia. LaToya's my third-favorite, then I guess Jasmine (she's usually good, and her family is so cute!)

I used to like Sinatra John but I think I'm getting tired of him. Never much liked Hobbit Jon but he seems to have a million adoring fans. Hobbits are 'in' this year!

Must go: Camile and Diana. I agree that Diana can sing but she reminds me of a grown-up child pageant star. Not in a good way.

George Huff is the man!!!!!

I actually like John Peter Lewis but agree he was off the past two weeks.

I think Camille is the next to go.

I can't stand Camille, I don't understand what words she's singing!!
I love George, he's so cute and innocent. He just looks soooo happy.

Fantasia is my favorite. YES, get rid of John Peter Lewis already...

All in all I was very disappointed last night...thought the show was kind of boring!

George, Latoya and Jasmine are my top three. I think John Stevens is the next to go. Although the idea of a crooner is pretty cool, there is no way he is suited to be an American Idol.

---

Posted by KathleenG

George, Latoya and Jasmine are my top three. I think John Stevens is the next to go. Although the idea of a crooner is pretty cool, there is no way he is suited to be an American Idol.

---

John Stevens is my man -- but I think he goes tonight, based on the judges comments last night

---

Posted by don424

---

Posted by KathleenG

George, Latoya and Jasmine are my top three. I think John Stevens is the next to go. Although the idea of a crooner is pretty cool, there is no way he is suited to be an American Idol.

---

John Stevens is my man -- but I think he goes tonight, based on the judges comments last night

---

No he can't go!! I voted for him 15 times!! I'm giving him another chance!! And I'd rather Camille go first!!!

No he can't go!! I voted for him 15 times!! I'm giving him another chance!! And I'd rather Camille go first!!!

---

He'll be in the bottom 3 -- hopefully someone else takes the hit, I like his voice

Him, Amy Adams and George Huff are my favorites

What is wrong with America?????

Why do they still vote Camille in? She is horrible horrible horrible I can't stand her and her stupid hand jestures. She is too street for me. The two Johns must go. I think Diana too...she is starting to annoy me...the typical teenager teeny bopper. Latoya outshines everyone, she rocks. I like George Huff too those two are my favorites.

I like Simon because to me he is the only honest one but sometimes he does get out of hand with his comments like telling amy she looks like jay leno. he can be a retard sometimes and I cannot stand Randy...errrrrrrrrr!!! how annoying!!!!!!!!!

I hate it when he is talking to a female contestant and says 'Yo dog' or 'dude'. Hello don't you know you are talking to a woman. If paula had half a brain she would say a comment to him about that or if i were a female constestant i would not want to be addressed as 'yo dog'. It's not right for male or female. this is Television, he thinks he's hanging in the streets. PATHETIC!!!!! GET A LIFE RANDY!

Yep, Randy is REALLY annoying. I liked him better last year, but now he's over the top with his stupid phrases and such.

As for Camile... she's probably still in there just because the entire state of Hawaii is voting for her!

hate it when he is talking to a female contestant and says 'Yo dog' or 'dude'. Hello don't you know you are talking to a woman. If paula had half a brain she would say a comment to him about that or if i were a female constestant i would not want to be addressed as 'yo dog'. It's not right for male or female. this is Television, he thinks he's hanging in the streets. PATHETIC!!!!! GET A LIFE RANDY!

---

Yo dog, it did your dog thing, dog, it was a'ight

And if Paula says, 'you made the song your own' or, 'you owned the stage tonight' I'm going to go nuts!