X-Post: Help choosing videographer

We were definitely NOT going to do a video and then all of a sudden I decided I want one - after looking at recap videos, I completely changed my mind. FH is not thrilled, but says if I want it, go for it. We met with two vendors this week. The first one, I really liked his work, but not overly thrilled with his personality (and FH definitely not a fan of the personality). the second one - tboth of us thought his personality was great, and his work was good, but I like the work of the first one better. FH says to do whatever I want (big help there ) (and these were the two that I spoke to that are 1) available for our date; 2) within our budget; and 3) I liked their video samples on their websites)
What would you do?