Anguilla Honeymoon help!!

We are currently looking into Anguilla for our honeymoon. We would like to stay 8 nights in Anguilla or split it with St. Barths (4 nts/4 nts or 5 nts/3 nts)!

Dates: 6/10/06 - 6/18/06
Anguilla: Cap Juluca or CuisinArt???
St. Barths: Isle de France or Guanahani???

OR should we skip St. Barths and stay at La Samanna in St. Maarten? There are so many options!

If anyone can prepare any quotes for us we would appreciate your help and any input!

Thanks,
Jess