American Idol

---

Posted by michellecarin

Did anyone just catch the middle finger that Simon gave to Ryan. Haha

---

no? When did that happen?

As for the results - I am sooo not amused that the blind guy made it to the Top 12. I think he's JUST ok, but nothing spectacular. I kind of assumed he'd probably make it thru tho, simply because of his situation. People always seem to vote for the 'sad story' rather than the talent. I think he's got a great personality and a good voice, but there were people in his group that sang a lot better, in my opinion, and deserved to make it way more than he did. So that was disappointing. (but I can't really complain since I don't ever vote. lol)

As for the wild card - I REALLY hope that Meghan continues. She's the only one I've heard so far that I actually could see myself buying a CD of. Everybody else just sounds way too common, but she has this cool older style voice. I absolutely adore it!

And what's with bringing back Tatianna????? What is going on here????

---

Posted by Mimacat

Is Megan the one who sang 'girl put your records on'? If so, I hate her and think her dancing is annoying and childish. I hope honestly, that only guys get through, b/c the girls really suck *** this season.

---

I definitely disagree with you on that one. I think that we definitely do have some good girl singers in the group. There's only about 2 guys so far in the top 12 that i like. And yes - that is Meghan you're thinking of. I think I was at first very turned off by all her tattoos and such (it was just too much) but then I heard her sing and wow - i love it! Everybody on the radio just sounds the same to me, so when i hear somebody that actually sounds DIFFERENT, I get really happy. Her voice just reminds me of the old classic singers, like somebody you'd hear singing at a Saloon. I dunno, I just really like it. Maybe I'll have to actually make myself VOTE this time. lol.

P.S: I'm sooo heartbroken that Nathaniel didn't make it lol. jk.

---

Posted by Mimacat

They should open some saloons around here. I'd love to be a bar wench.

---

ME TOO!!! Esp if I can wear one of those big fluffy saloon dresses, with the feathered hat deal Yeah, I'd be hott in that

---

Posted by RockysGirl

---

Posted by michellecarin

Did anyone just catch the middle finger that Simon gave to Ryan. Haha

---

no? When did that happen?

As for the results - I am sooo not amused that the blind guy made it to the Top 12. I think he's JUST ok, but nothing spectacular. I kind of assumed he'd probably make it thru tho, simply because of his situation. People always seem to vote for the 'sad story' rather than the talent. I think he's got a great personality and a good voice, but there were people in his group that sang a lot better, in my opinion, and deserved to make it way more than he did. So that was disappointing. (but I can't really complain since I don't ever vote. lol)

As for the wild card - I REALLY hope that Meghan continues. She's the only one I've heard so far that I actually could see myself buying a CD of. Everybody else just sounds way too common, but she has this cool older style voice. I absolutely adore it!

And what's with bringing back Tatianna????? What is going on here????

---

i think the blind guy is alot better than just about all the wild card ppl except for anoop.

---

Posted by Espo22

---

Posted by RockysGirl

---

Posted by michellecarin

Did anyone just catch the middle finger that Simon gave to Ryan. Haha

---

no? When did that happen?

As for the results - I am sooo not amused that the blind guy made it to the Top 12. I think he's JUST ok, but nothing spectacular. I kind of assumed he'd probably make it thru tho, simply because of his situation. People always seem to vote for the 'sad story' rather than the talent. I think he's got a great personality and a good voice, but there were people in his group that sang a lot better, in my opinion, and deserved to make it way more than he did. So that was disappointing. (but I can't really complain since I don't ever vote. lol)

As for the wild card - I REALLY hope that Meghan continues. She's the only one I've heard so far that I actually could see myself buying a CD of. Everybody else just sounds way too common, but she has this cool older style voice. I absolutely adore it!

And what's with bringing back Tatianna????? What is going on here????

---

i think the blind guy is alot better than just about all the wild card ppl except for anoop.

---

Amen.

The only 2 I'm sad not to see again are Felicia and Kristin. As for the others, they all suck, as do all of those wild card ppl.

OK I am probably going to get flamed for this but...I think Anoop S U C K S, he reminds me of the days that Simon thought Sunjia was a stronger singer compared to his sister. 'A-Dog, Anoop Dog, A to the N to the double O...P equates to better singers not getting into the top 12!

Tatiana reminds me of those blisters that you get from really amazing shoes...you know the ones, they are gorgeous on the rack, you try them on, they fit as if they are a second skin and your foot was born to wear them, so you buy. Then you wear them once and get blood blisters. Once those blisters heal, you try to wear them again and you get those blisters back, and its this never ending cycle of listening to Tatiana sing and then bleeding. Sorry but I just can't stand her! Between her nervous laugh, whiny wanna be Whitney Houston voice, and her unnecessary crying for vocal coach help tears, it makes me wish for the days Deanna DiGarmo sang and butchered Donna Summers.



Sorry for the harshness but if Paula Abdul can go on camera as hiped up on pain killers and stupidity as she has for the last two nights...I am totally thinking her job is mine come next season once her contract is up!!!!!!!!!!

---

Posted by Mimacat

Is Megan the one who sang 'girl put your records on'? If so, I hate her and think her dancing is annoying and childish. I hope honestly, that only guys get through, b/c the girls really suck *** this season.

---

DH was like what the F*CK is she doing with her hips??? im like umm dancing lol he was like oh wow yeah she suucks at life

Meghans a cute girl but she was painful to watch. I dont know what that swinging thing she does is, but i was embarrassed for her. I wanted Ju-no (sp?) to get through - he sung hey there delilah. I thought he was good. I cant believe they kept tatiana - shes a disaster.

---

Posted by kristi313

I despise tatiana, i think they judges are all morons

---

unfortunately, they had to put her through....drama = ratings

---

Posted by thenewmrsharrington

---

Posted by kristi313

I despise tatiana, i think they judges are all morons

---

unfortunately, they had to put her through....drama = ratings

---

I totally agree that it was all for dramatic affect. The writers prob told them they HAD to choose her as 1 of the 8 to come back just for ratings. And even how Simon made sure to stress that they ALL chose her and wanted her back. Gag me!

I really wish they would have put through Felicia and Kristin (the blond who can sing but has bad clothes) I thought they were the only two girls (besides Lil) that have decent voices.

I hate Von b/c he looks like a life size version of a My Buddy doll.

---

Posted by SparkyandAng

I disagree with almost all the wild card choices, specifically Tatiana. I feel bad for Felicia I thought she was great and to get sent home, called backed, kicked off, and then not picked for the wild card is just wrong. She looked soo upset.

---

I SO AGREE!!!!!


i so wish Tatiana, didnt make it, they prob only did it for tv/rating