honeymoon help

I need input from sandals couples. I am torn between st.lucia regency and all of the Jamaicas. They are in my price range. We like nightlife and entertainment until 1 or 2 in the am. Which one is hopping at night??? Any other aspects to consider. My fh doesn't really want Jamaica because he doesn't want to be tied to the resort. Suggestions.
thanks

I didn't go to Sandals, but our best man and his wife and one of our gm and his wife both went on their hm there (St Lucia one) in November 2003 and both couples were really unhappy with it. We went to Royal Hideaway and spent the same amt of money as our best man and got so much more. They are now planning a trip to RH and say they regret ever going to Sandals. I also have a coworker that went to Sandals and complained to them to get some money reimbursed b/c it was horrible (I forget which island). I've personally never been so I can't speak first hand but I just wanted to give you something else to consider. Good Luck!