American Idol

What did everyone think of tonight's performances?? I loved Ruben-he is great every week- & Rickey Smith sang my wedding sooo well!! I had tears in my eyes!! I love Clay but he wasn't as good as usual--feel bad for Carmen-seems likes a sweet girl but everyone dumps on her! I don't usually like Kimberely Locke but she sounded good & wore a more appropiate outfit tonight. Kimberely Caldwell sounded OK-I like the way she handles the criticism from the judges. Josh Gracin picked a good song-he had to make a come back from last week--wasn't nuts about him though this week. Trenyce soudned pretty good--but she bothers me-she needs to go-

Lionel Richie was a great guest judge--much better than that weirdo last week!

Lionel Richie looked great i was hoping he was gonna sing ROOOOOOOO-BENNNNNN was awesome

I missed it Please give a review, someone, anyone

Here is how I liked them:

Reuben-Was on point!!!! LOVED him!!!

Josh-SO HAPPY!! That is a maybe on my wedding song. And he sang it amazingly

Kimberley Locke-Very Good

Clay-I thought he was going to nail that song. But not so much.

Rickey-Did a good job. I usually don't like him. But I did tonight.

Trenynce-She was ok. Like Endlessluv said I just don't like her. I don't know why.

Kimberley Caldwell-Looked great. Should of sang something more lively. I was dissappointed.

Carmen-HORRIBLE!!!!!!

I as well think Carmen is going tomorrow although i do think whoever does get voted off they will have a promising career I hope you all voted for ROOOOOOOOOO-BENNNNNNN

Chipp doesnt Cher look great

She does. I was on the phone with a friend and we both said we hope to look as good as Cher. Then again Cher paid a lot of money for her face.

But she looks amazing. Her outfits are so out of control. Did you see when she first came in wearing the fur???

YA i love her headpieces she rocks

I love how they showed a sonny and cher song. That was great.

She is so fit. I cant believe she is retiring. I keep saying she'll come back. She'll be like Celine Dion she cant be away for long

She will be back i think also,she is a legend

My review:

Clay - good as usual, I love him, not jaw dropping tho' for some reason...

Ruben - Does it get any better? He is on point, every time !!!!I love this man !!!!!

Kimberly Locke - Pretty good, I liked it

Kimberly Caldwell - hated her song, hated her

Carmen - I may vote for her once because I feel so sorry for her, but she does have to go, I think it's about time now

Josh - I was really pushing for him to make a comeback, and I think he did

Trenyce - I think she was great

Rickey - LOVED his performance tonight !!!!!!!

She's been around forever, she cant leave. There are just certain performars that just can never retire and she is one of them.

edited to add: I wish Bette Midler would do something like this. I LOVE the divine Miss M

8:30 pm

looooooooooooooooooooooove Cher!! Saw her concert out here in RI and also saw it at MSG....she is such a great perfomrer..the concert on TV is the one I saw...she is just unbelievable!! And D@mn, I'd loooove to looik like her at that age, he ll, I would love to look like her at this age!!!!!!!!

Hahhahahah

BTW---American Idol...looove looove loove Josh...none of the girls were so hot tonight..and clay did not sing his heart out tonight, but Roooooooooooooooooo-ben ROCKS@!!!! I loove when his cheekbones go up and he tries not to smile!! Was glad to see Kimberly Lock with relaxed hair!!! Last week was outta control!!

My parents saw her a few years ago in Jones Beach and my mom loved the concert. She said Cher gives an amazing concert.

I love Cher. I want her to sing 'if I could turn back time'

I've always loved that song...

What is up with Carmen's voice when she sings and it kind of vibrates...I can't believe she's gotten this far!!