American Idol Question

RedHead Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:43 PM

American Idol Question

Do you really see any of these people as an american idol...

I have YET to see anyone of the past winners as an AMERICAN IDOL...

It definately appeals to the teenie poppers and middle-menopause aged woman but ...

AN AMERICAN IDOL...NO..none of them..
Good singers yea...making money sure...but not an idol by any means

Happybride2005 Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:44 PM

Re: American Idol Question

if they do charity work, would that be an idol

Butterflybride Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:45 PM

Re: American Idol Question

I honestly thought Kelly Clarkson was the best 'idol' out of any of the winners, but no, most of these people aren't idols by any means.

Shorty McBride Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:45 PM

Re: American Idol Question

lol... word.

Happybride2005 Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:50 PM

Re: American Idol Question

some of the singers out there, i don't see them as idols. i know clay aiken does charity work and works with kids

Butterflybride Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:52 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by Happybride2005

some of the singers out there, i don't see them as idols. i know clay aiken does charity work and works with kids

That's true. I picture an idol as somebody that tries to appeal to all age groups though. Most people I know that like Clay though are older women. He doesn't really appeal to men or younger women. He's a great singer though.

RedHead Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:53 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by Butterflybride

Posted by Happybride2005

some of the singers out there, i don't see them as idols. i know clay aiken does charity work and works with kids

That's true. I picture an idol as somebody that tries to appeal to all age groups though. Most people I know that like Clay though are older women. He doesn't really appeal to men or younger women. He's a great singer though.

anyone can do charity work...that doesn't make them a idol...

Clay...well he just reminds me of a scarecrow

Happybride2005 Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:56 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by oct.2004bride

Posted by Butterflybride

Posted by Happybride2005

some of the singers out there, i don't see them as idols. i know clay aiken does charity work and works with kids

That's true. I picture an idol as somebody that tries to appeal to all age groups though. Most people I know that like Clay though are older women. He doesn't really appeal to men or younger women. He's a great singer though.

anyone can do charity work...that doesn't make them a idol...

Clay...well he just reminds me of a scarecrow

the teeny boopers out there today, i sure i don't seem them as an idol

RedHead Posted: Mar 07, 2005 08:59 PM

Re: American Idol Question

eh?
I think they do...who else goes to see him in concert...all middle aged women?

FeliciaDA Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:13 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by oct.2004bride
Clay...well he just reminds me of a scarecrow

OMG truly I could not agree more! I simply dont get what people see in Clay whatsoever.. he's just so 'BLAH' .. even his singing .. BLAH..

As for thinking these pepoel are 'idols' .. well HELL NO, I don't think ANY of them are 'idol worthy' or worth half of the accolades they wind up receiving. I bet you that the majority of them aren't half as good as most of the people that you'd see off-broadway or playing in a nightclub

.. this show always manages to disappoint me in the end .. I'm not even sure why I still watch

julz33 Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:14 PM

Re: American Idol Question

I think Clay was the best singer put of the firat 3 seasons.

Butterflybride Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:18 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by julz33

I think Clay was the best singer put of the firat 3 seasons.

And he didn't even win . I don't even know why I keep watching this show

RedHead Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:20 PM

Re: American Idol Question

clay Aiken reminds me of a broadway singer...that is it...

NOT an americal pop star BY ANY MEANS

julz33 Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:25 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by oct.2004bride

clay Aiken reminds me of a broadway singer...that is it...

NOT an americal pop star BY ANY MEANS

Maybe he does sound like a broadway singer... why is that a bad thing? If you watched the show all of his performances were flawless.
Kristen, it doesn't matter that he didn't 'win' he is very sucessful without the title of American Idol. What ever happened to Ruben

FeliciaDA Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:27 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Yeah Ruben isn't doing half as well as Clay..

But I think the biggest 'loser' was Justin from season 1 ... his career totally took a nosedive after that stupid movie he made with Kelly Clarkson . I could not STAND Justin

MrsTC Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:27 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Maybe Mario Vasquez or Anwar Robinson? Even Carrie Underwood?

Butterflybride Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:28 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by julz33

Posted by oct.2004bride

clay Aiken reminds me of a broadway singer...that is it...

NOT an americal pop star BY ANY MEANS

Maybe he does sound like a broadway singer... why is that a bad thing? If you watched the show all of his performances were flawless.
Kristen, it doesn't matter that he didn't 'win' he is very sucessful without the title of American Idol. What ever happened to Ruben

I know, it just ticks me off that he didn't win, because he really did deserve it. His fans stuck with him though, despite that and his record sales were amazing. Ruben had ONE song come out and then he fell off the face of the earth

Butterflybride Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:28 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by FeliciaDA

Yeah Ruben isn't doing half as well as Clay..

But I think the biggest 'loser' was Justin from season 1 ... his career totally took a nosedive after that stupid movie he made with Kelly Clarkson . I could not STAND Justin

Oh my god, I actually WATCHED that garbage too! Terrible terrible movie

1017Bride Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:29 PM

Re: American Idol Question

There are a few that have possibilities but there is not as much idol potential as season 2.

RedHead Posted: Mar 07, 2005 09:29 PM

Re: American Idol Question

Posted by julz33

Posted by oct.2004bride

clay Aiken reminds me of a broadway singer...that is it...

NOT an americal pop star BY ANY MEANS

Maybe he does sound like a broadway singer... why is that a bad thing? If you watched the show all of his performances were flawless.
Kristen, it doesn't matter that he didn't 'win' he is very sucessful without the title of American Idol. What ever happened to Ruben

I didn't say that was bad...but he isn't an AMERICAN IDOL...
You will not see anyone trying to look like him, dress like him, sing like him...
That is what i meant

Successful YES he was...

But i guess i just feel the whole meaning of the show is silly...NONE of these people are or will ever be AMERICAN IDOLS