American Idol Tonight

This song Fantasia ia singin..I sang like 10-12 years ago with my cousin in a karoke booth at the Polish Festival in Riverhead!! OMG..I remember like it was yesterday!!!

Not to mention...we were not even close to how AWESOME she is!

OK- completely superficial --- I cannot stop staring at Katie Weber's nose. What is with it?

I LOVED Fantasia!! You go girl!

---

Posted by ThongLori

OK- completely superficial --- I cannot stop staring at Katie Weber's nose. What is with it?

---

She kinda reminded me of Debbie Gibson!

---

Posted by Anniegrl

---

Posted by ThongLori

OK- completely superficial --- I cannot stop staring at Katie Weber's nose. What is with it?

---

She kinda reminded me of Debbie Gibson!

---

Ya she does!!

Fantasia is Hotttttttttttttt!
I love her and and she has my vote

Hands down, Katie Webber was the best the show had to offer! I hope she wins the whole damn thing. That girl has it goin' on with her stage presence and her performance abilities. Who gives a crap about her nose??? Barbara Streisand's nose is the REASON she can sing so well!

i liked katie, diana and fantasia.

i voted for diana on the phone. she is 16 and has so much stage presence. i thought she was terrific!

---

Posted by Danielle&Scott

I still think the two girls I picked before the show did the best. Fantasia has such a strange voice. I couldnt believe what Simon said about her not needing american idol to become a music star. I really did not like the sound of her voice. She kind of reminded me of a female version of Steve Erkel.

---

I agree with this 100%
While I'm watching my sister and I are in disbelief that they are complimenting her so much.
I thought she was horrible b/c I didnt think her voice matched the song at all.
I like that song a lot, but her voice is not meant for country.

My favorite was Katie, but she sang an older song and I don't think that was a good choice. The younger crowd wont relate to it.

I think she had the best voice and stage presence.

---

Posted by Sassy

---

Posted by Danielle&Scott

I still think the two girls I picked before the show did the best. Fantasia has such a strange voice. I couldnt believe what Simon said about her not needing american idol to become a music star. I really did not like the sound of her voice. She kind of reminded me of a female version of Steve Erkel.

---

I agree with this 100%
While I'm watching my sister and I are in disbelief that they are complimenting her so much.
I thought she was horrible b/c I didnt think her voice matched the song at all.
I like that song a lot, but her voice is not meant for country.

---

I AGREE!!! I was shocked and then I come into work and the other secretary here thought I was NUTS thinking that she wasn't good!!! I could've sung that song better!

Anyway, I was a loser and I did vote! I voted for Diana (I think that's her name), the 16 year old from Georgia, she went first, sang I've got the Music in Me.

I like Diana and Kaite the most. Katie's performance was so sassy and entertaining.

Fantasia was OK, I agree with the judges that she is unique and had good stage presence. But I didn't like the tone of her voice....I am not into the Macy Gray sound.

The young 16 year old girl that went first (Diana ) has my vote. She seems so sweet and is really talented. Fantasia-she has an okay voice---it's different and that is what I guess prompted Simon to say what he did--i was shocked, i thought he was going to tear her performance apart.

someone mentioned the red hair crooner kid--i think he got eliminated last week! i liked him, too!

---

Posted by endlessluv429

someone mentioned the red hair crooner kid--i think he got eliminated last week! i liked him, too!

---

Nope he is in the final 32. Not sure when he will preform though

My three favorites from last night were Diana, Katie and Fantasia...

Fantasia does have a Macy Gray sort of sound...and I really like that...it's different.

From last year, Corey Clark had such a different sound, which is why I liked him too.