We *finally* booked ours yesterday (Aruba!) but we had MAJOR honeymoon issues! It seemed like the more we looked the harder it was to decide and tripadvisor was great but also annoying b/c god forbid a place had a slightly negative review..we were both scared to go Anyways, just wanted to add in that Aruba is a pretty safe bet if you want an island but no hurricane issues...it's out of the hurricane belt.. part of the reason we choose it. Also I agree check the weather for when you are going..we were thinking Bermuda but it's supposed to be cooler there in April so it was out!