BM Dress opinions needed!

Hi Gals,

Here are two pictures of dresses i'm debating with. Both dresses are by Alfred Angelo and they are in the color that I want- light blue. My BMs range in ages and in sizes so i want the dress to be flattering and appropriate for all of them and I don't want them spending a small fortune either. With that said- I'd like to get opinions on these dresses. Thanks.