Post New Topic

Cake poll

GettinHutched Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by lizzynyu

They are both really cute ideas but if you are going with a Yankee theme, you should definitely do the 2nd cake only because the yankee pinstripes go down. I love the idea though! Very original!



Now ya got me thinkin'! We gotta have the inter-locking NY logo at the top of the cake!

So kidding!!! Now THAT would be going overboard!

Would look mighty frickin' cool though!
HamptonsBride Posted:

Re: Cake poll

Let's Go Yankees!!! #2
billandme Posted:

Re: Cake poll

LOVE no. 2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
stealthgroom Posted:

Re: Cake poll

Wanna know what you need to do, sis? I'll tell you. you need to do this on your cake.

Don't mind me, just trying to live vicariously through your awesome yankees themed wedding. too bad fw is a mets fan. sigh.

seriously, though, if you found a cake company that would do the facade on your cake, i might help pay for the detail on principle.
GettinHutched Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by stealthgroom

Wanna know what you need to do, sis? I'll tell you. you need to do this on your cake.

Don't mind me, just trying to live vicariously through your awesome yankees themed wedding. too bad fw is a mets fan. sigh.

seriously, though, if you found a cake company that would do the facade on your cake, i might help pay for the detail on principle.



OMG OMG OMG! I was wondering when my 'bro' would post to this thread!!! THAT IS BRILLIANT!!! Oh man I have no idea how that would happen but WOW! What an idea!

Why can't you have a half Yankee/half Met theme? I was searching for Yankee wedding themes and I saw a Yankee/Red Sox wedding! You can do it!!!!

DUDE! Why did you have to give me this idea? I can only imagine how $$$ it would be!!!! SOOO COOL!!!
IlianaR Posted:

Re: Cake poll

I love the second one and I def. don't think it's too much as long as you stay within ur ideas. I love the thin stripe idea. It's perfect!I can't wait to see pics!

stealthgroom Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by GettinHutched

OMG OMG OMG! I was wondering when my 'bro' would post to this thread!!! THAT IS BRILLIANT!!! Oh man I have no idea how that would happen but WOW! What an idea!

Why can't you have a half Yankee/half Met theme? I was searching for Yankee wedding themes and I saw a Yankee/Red Sox wedding! You can do it!!!!

DUDE! Why did you have to give me this idea? I can only imagine how $$$ it would be!!!! SOOO COOL!!!



We can't do that, honestly... FW doesn't even want a theme, and her folks would NOT go for a baseball theme (they're good folks, but in some ways, they're kinda old fashioned)

Like I said, sis, living vicariously through you. It may be too much, pricewise, and if so, I'd go with the stripes down, but maybe a likkel thinner.

wouldn't that be the sh!t, though? if I win the megamillions, I'm getting a freaking yankee stadium facade cake.

--the stealth groom
(because real baseball is in less than 7 weeks!)
lizzynyu Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by stealthgroom

Wanna know what you need to do, sis? I'll tell you. you need to do this on your cake.

Don't mind me, just trying to live vicariously through your awesome yankees themed wedding. too bad fw is a mets fan. sigh.

seriously, though, if you found a cake company that would do the facade on your cake, i might help pay for the detail on principle.



That is such an AWESOME idea! OMG. I love it. I just can't let my FH see this board or else he'll be so quick to throw out our martini themed wedding (which he came up with...lol) and he'll want to do a Yankee wedding...LOL. Such great ideas.
GettinHutched Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by stealthgroom


We can't do that, honestly... FW doesn't even want a theme, and her folks would NOT go for a baseball theme (they're good folks, but in some ways, they're kinda old fashioned)

Like I said, sis, living vicariously through you. It may be too much, pricewise, and if so, I'd go with the stripes down, but maybe a likkel thinner.

wouldn't that be the sh!t, though? if I win the megamillions, I'm getting a freaking yankee stadium facade cake.

--the stealth groom
(because real baseball is in less than 7 weeks!)



OMG that would be friggin' awesome!!!

My mom keeps saying 'You're too much' with my ideas- she's pretty old fashioned too! She was all grossed out with my navy invites!!!
stealthgroom Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by lizzynyu

That is such an AWESOME idea! OMG. I love it. I just can't let my FH see this board or else he'll be so quick to throw out our martini themed wedding (which he came up with...lol) and he'll want to do a Yankee wedding...LOL. Such great ideas.



Ah Lizzynyu, your wedding is in november, there's still time!



seriously though, one of the reasons i've been active on here as a groom is to find out more about this stuff, since i've been doing a lot of the initial vendor legwork with fw in the classroom all day,. Also, I get to be a to be a voice out there as part of this conversation, which I feel like can always help the fellas who don't know about this stuff, and the ladies who would like a guy's perspective.

but seriously, though, there's still time. you could do a yankees theme wedding. EVERYONE SHOULD DO ONE (since I can't)

--the stealth groom
(giving meat eating, sports watching, whiskey drinking guys a voice on liweddings since 10/06)
GettinHutched Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by lizzynyu


That is such an AWESOME idea! OMG. I love it. I just can't let my FH see this board or else he'll be so quick to throw out our martini themed wedding (which he came up with...lol) and he'll want to do a Yankee wedding...LOL. Such great ideas.



Thank you so much! I can't take credit for all of them....but I'm pretty excited about it too!!!

princessofci did a yankee theme too...just waiting on more of her pics!!!
stealthgroom Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by GettinHutched

Thank you so much! I can't take credit for all of them....but I'm pretty excited about it too!!!

princessofci did a yankee theme too...just waiting on more of her pics!!!



hey sis, did Sarahradio do any yankee themed stuff? trying to remember
GettinHutched Posted:

Re: Cake poll

don't think so...although she did use 'Ready 4 this' as the music for her BP to enter, which is what I'm using as well. There might have been little Yankee mentions though- I think her table numbers each represented places and things they like to do......

NovemberBride07 just answered my FM- she said the facade really wouldn't be that difficult to do!!! Ooooh this might be possible! You're a genius, bro!!!

Think it's crazy to go with navy pinstripes gown the cake, with the facade going around the bottom of each tier? Aye yi yi...might as well make a stadium cake!
lizzynyu Posted:

Re: Cake poll



Ah Lizzynyu, your wedding is in november, there's still time!



seriously though, one of the reasons i've been active on here as a groom is to find out more about this stuff, since i've been doing a lot of the initial vendor legwork with fw in the classroom all day,. Also, I get to be a to be a voice out there as part of this conversation, which I feel like can always help the fellas who don't know about this stuff, and the ladies who would like a guy's perspective.

but seriously, though, there's still time. you could do a yankees theme wedding. EVERYONE SHOULD DO ONE (since I can't)

--the stealth groom
(giving meat eating, sports watching, whiskey drinking guys a voice on liweddings since 10/06)



I love that there is a guy's perspective on here! It's so awesome. My FH acted like it was my show and that he'd be happy with whatever I wanted and yet everytime we went to a vendor, he kept throwing out these great ideas, like the whole martini theme which I was like completely shocked! And then he came up with centerpiece ideas to incorporate the theme and it was so great. He's a HUGE Yankees fan but we're gonna stick to the martini theme...and although I like the Yankees, if we were gonna do any sports team we'd be having a NY Giants wedding theme since I'm a HUGE football fan...LOL
stealthgroom Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by GettinHutched

don't think so...although she did use 'Ready 4 this' as the music for her BP to enter, which is what I'm using as well. There might have been little Yankee mentions though- I think her table numbers each represented places and things they like to do......

NovemberBride07 just answered my FM- she said the facade really wouldn't be that difficult to do!!! Ooooh this might be possible! You're a genius, bro!!!

Think it's crazy to go with navy pinstripes gown the cake, with the facade going around the bottom of each tier? Aye yi yi...might as well make a stadium cake!





no freaking way. that would be amazing!!! and no, unsurprisingly, I don't think it would be too much to do pinstripes plus the facade.



woohoo!

--the stealth groom
(because real baseball is less than 7 weeks away!)
Fara Posted:

Re: Cake poll

Even though I am a Mets fan... I love the stripes! I think it would be perfect for your theme.

I wish I had a theme.
BunnyBride Posted:

Re: Cake poll

I LOOOOVE the stripey one!! Very elegant and fun! Much more unique then the first one
PegaLega Posted:

Re: Cake poll

I would normally say #1...but b/c you are trying to do a Yankee theme I would definitely do the second one...its more yankee like to me. Maybe you could just make the stripes a little skinnier instead of even

AlBaBride Posted:

Re: Cake poll


Posted by ido06

I definitely think # 2 is more 'yankee' like., and will get the idea across....but if you are already incorporating a lot of yankee-related ideas then # 1 might be more subtle.



I agree...I think it would go so well with your theme
snydl40 Posted:

Re: Cake poll

#2

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.