Churches near Fox Hollow

I've tried looking through the boards and haven't really found a ton of info so I'm starting my own post...My FH and I are looking for a church (Protestant or Unitarian or other type that's not too restrictive) that isn't too modern looking near the Fox Hollow. The Historical Chapel is too small and we may look at the Unitarian one in Manhasset. A helpful bride gave me a tip on hers but FH wanted something with an older feel. Any ideas?

Thanks in advance!