Post New Topic

Depressing Christmas music...

Original post by BMD'sPeanut

Can someone please explain to me the appeal of: 'I wanna buy new shoes for my Mamma...blah, blah, blah...'

WTH is that???

That's not happy. That's not Christmasy...

And Celine Dion's 'O Holy Night' ...I wanted to slit my wrists right there in the nail salon.

How annoying.
tracyg Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by brideinapril

Okay - I actually like the song - it gives me a sense of what I have and that there are other people in the world who aren't as well off.

Also I thought Jesus was RESURRECTED in the spring. Correct me if I am wrong though.


not sure what that has to do with when he was born. He was born in the spring, and died in spring (or that could be wrong too).
But the point is, Christianity stole it's religious timeframe from the Pagans.
brideinapril Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by tracyg


Posted by brideinapril

Okay - I actually like the song - it gives me a sense of what I have and that there are other people in the world who aren't as well off.

Also I thought Jesus was RESURRECTED in the spring. Correct me if I am wrong though.


not sure what that has to do with when he was born. He was born in the spring, and died in spring (or that could be wrong too).
But the point is, Christianity stole it's religious timeframe from the Pagans.



I did believe that he was born on christmas and died during the spring and was resurrected on Easter -
I brought this up because one of the other posters on this mentioned that he was born and died in spring.
Good Friday is supposed to be the day that marks when he was crucified on the cross.
tourist Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by kdelace

to be honest, none of the osngs are doing it for me this year.... I guess thats what happens when you get married and separated all in the same year....



Not even Feliz Navidad? In HS, my friend & were firm believers that no one could listen to that song without dancing!

FeliciaDA Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by MonkeyLuv

Because the holiday season is a time for shmaltzy music played in the background of hermetically-sealed malls while over-worked and under-paid people get into fistfights over the year's hottest toy.





Just had to give props to my girl MonkeyLuv. This was THE quote of the thread..... Bravo, bravo!!

I don't have much to add about the subject matter. As Don knows () I'm not a huge fan of holiday music on a whole. So really the shoe song doens't affect me one way of the other - I basically turn it off like I do most holiday tunes.

I know - bah humbug to me

Sorry , didn't mean to hijack the topic at hand! Me bad
MonkeyLuv Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by FeliciaDA


Just had to give props to my girl MonkeyLuv. This was THE quote of the thread..... Bravo, bravo!!

I don't have much to add about the subject matter. As Don knows () I'm not a huge fan of holiday music on a whole. So really the shoe song doens't affect me one way of the other - I basically turn it off like I do most holiday tunes.

I know - bah humbug to me

Sorry , didn't mean to hijack the topic at hand! Me bad



Felicia....aww thanks!

After all, isn't that what this season is all about? repetitive and pointed music, arguing over the religious and non-religious aspects of a holiday, coma-inducing baked goods, and hundreds of dollars worth of plastic crap that will be broken before New Year's shoved under a wilting tree in the hopes of instilling goodwill and hope in the bitter, bitter hearts of cunsumers?

aahh, comfort and joy...
sarahthegreat Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by cluelessbride


Posted by MonkeyLuv

I was stuck on the 135 in an unholy snowstorm last year and that freaking 'christmas shoes' song came on the radio. I wanted to eat broken glass.





I can't stand the song b/c it's just so BAD!

I'll take John Lennon's Christmas-Peace-on-Earth song as a 'let's remember how fortunate we are and make the world a better place' type song any day over the offensive shoe song.



totally agree on all points. give me john lennon any day. 'shoes' is a schmaltzy tug at you to make you feel bad about what you have. i does get to me, but i try to not listen to it.
tracyg Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by brideinapril


Posted by tracyg


Posted by brideinapril

Okay - I actually like the song - it gives me a sense of what I have and that there are other people in the world who aren't as well off.

Also I thought Jesus was RESURRECTED in the spring. Correct me if I am wrong though.


not sure what that has to do with when he was born. He was born in the spring, and died in spring (or that could be wrong too).
But the point is, Christianity stole it's religious timeframe from the Pagans.



I did believe that he was born on christmas and died during the spring and was resurrected on Easter -
I brought this up because one of the other posters on this mentioned that he was born and died in spring.
Good Friday is supposed to be the day that marks when he was crucified on the cross.



And they are right. It is historically (not Bible based) believed that he was born in Spring.
brideinapril Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by tracyg


Posted by brideinapril


Posted by tracyg


Posted by brideinapril

Okay - I actually like the song - it gives me a sense of what I have and that there are other people in the world who aren't as well off.

Also I thought Jesus was RESURRECTED in the spring. Correct me if I am wrong though.


not sure what that has to do with when he was born. He was born in the spring, and died in spring (or that could be wrong too).
But the point is, Christianity stole it's religious timeframe from the Pagans.



I did believe that he was born on christmas and died during the spring and was resurrected on Easter -
I brought this up because one of the other posters on this mentioned that he was born and died in spring.
Good Friday is supposed to be the day that marks when he was crucified on the cross.



And they are right. It is historically (not Bible based) believed that he was born in Spring.



ahhh, I see now.
Sassyz75 Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by BMD'sPeanut


Posted by MonkeyLuv

Meanwhile, not once did I hear Eartha Kitt purring out 'Santa Baby'!



You can hear her if you take a NYC cab!
'Purrrrrr...fasten your seatbelt....Meow'



LOL
I LOVE when I get into a cab that has her@

I despise the Rockette Cabs!!!
lorsin Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...

Soooo.....back on the topic of depressing Christmas Music. The songs that make me cry are:

I'll Be Home for Christmas (especially the last couple years)

3000 Miles (The Pretenders)

Have Your Self A Merry Little Christmas (especially the James Taylor version)

Keep Christmas With You (from Christmas Eve on Sesame Street...yes, I'm 29 and I still watch that!!)

I just sit an weep under my tree!! Then I put on the Muppets version of the 12 days of Christmas and all is right with the world!!

5 Golden Rings...Ba-da-bum-bum!!

sarahthegreat Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by lorsin

Soooo.....back on the topic of depressing Christmas Music. The songs that make me cry are:

I'll Be Home for Christmas (especially the last couple years)

3000 Miles (The Pretenders)

Have Your Self A Merry Little Christmas (especially the James Taylor version)

Keep Christmas With You (from Christmas Eve on Sesame Street...yes, I'm 29 and I still watch that!!)

I just sit an weep under my tree!! Then I put on the Muppets version of the 12 days of Christmas and all is right with the world!!

5 Golden Rings...Ba-da-bum-bum!!

love the muppets christmas album. thats a classic.

also love 3000 miles, not really a christmas song, but very good.


tourist Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by lorsin



Keep Christmas With You (from Christmas Eve on Sesame Street...yes, I'm 29 and I still watch that!!)






I have that video! I love that song. I always try & learn the signing to go with it.
bluegrl24ny Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by xjulietx

I don't like the song. I think it is melodramatic and was written to tug at the heartstrings.

I cried the first time I heard it and then I realized that they got me sucked in.




I COMPLETELY agree with Juliet on this one. I heard this song for the first time the other day and instead of being upset by it - I was actually pretty annoyed and more pissed off than anything.... Not for nothing, but this song is pretty low considering it's exploiting some poor kid's innocent gesture for his sick mom. I know these things do happen in real life, but it's a little shameless for someone to be making money of this 'sad Christmas song' at the expense of catering to our emotions.... As a song in general, it's a bit much on the tugging at hearstring level - but to make it a CHRISTMAS song.... really doesnt make much sense to me - but I'm sure it's selling like crazy, the obvious reason for it's purpose in the first place. Ah, love the capitalism.....
Kriss2c Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...

I wonder how much the holiday-suicide rate will increase due to this song??
bluegrl24ny Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by Kriss2c

I wonder how much the holiday-suicide rate will increase due to this song??




Right?!? Like the holidays don't evoke enough emotions as it is, let's add some more to it! Enough with the sap already!
BMD'sPeanut Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...

hey now!

StepherG Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...

I hate all the music this year and I cant get away from it wherever I go...My dad passed away this year and holidays will NEVER be the same....I actually started crying at the nail salon I miss my dad.
FeliciaDA Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by StepherG

I hate all the music this year and I cant get away from it wherever I go...My dad passed away this year and holidays will NEVER be the same....I actually started crying at the nail salon I miss my dad.



Oh I am so sorry

I agree that the music seems like it is everywhere, all the time... and if I'd suffered a loss as you did, I would be crying all the time as well

Hang in there - i cannot imagine what a difficult time this is for you!!!

StepherG Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by FeliciaDA


Posted by StepherG

I hate all the music this year and I cant get away from it wherever I go...My dad passed away this year and holidays will NEVER be the same....I actually started crying at the nail salon I miss my dad.



Oh I am so sorry

I agree that the music seems like it is everywhere, all the time... and if I'd suffered a loss as you did, I would be crying all the time as well

Hang in there - i cannot imagine what a difficult time this is for you!!!




Thanks. I never realized how hard it would be to avoid this holiday...it's EVERYWHERE!!
cocoa Posted:

Re: Depressing Christmas music...


Posted by smm2675


Posted by cluelessbride


Posted by MonkeyLuv

I was stuck on the 135 in an unholy snowstorm last year and that freaking 'christmas shoes' song came on the radio. I wanted to eat broken glass.





I can't stand the song b/c it's just so BAD!

I'll take John Lennon's Christmas-Peace-on-Earth song as a 'let's remember how fortunate we are and make the world a better place' type song any day over the offensive shoe song.



totally agree on all points. give me john lennon any day. 'shoes' is a schmaltzy tug at you to make you feel bad about what you have. i does get to me, but i try to not listen to it.



i have to laugh at this b/c the muppet christmas album with john denver is one of my favorites and as i was reading this, i was thinking 'yeah, more muppet lovers!'

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.