Dress Help

I thought I had my dress but I tried on another dress the other day and now having second thoughts.

Please help me decide which dress you think looks best?

http://fashionbride.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/palma_b1.jpg


(I would remove the halter on the dress above)

Or this one:

http://www.maggiesottero.com/dress.aspx?keywordText=3325&keywordType=any&page=0&pageSize=12&style=A3325SS

(I would remove the strap as well)

Thanks for your help!

They are both very pretty dresses, but they are very different looks. First question is does one look better ON YOU than the other? Like fits your body, makes you feel beautiful, gives you THAT feeling, is YOU, like you put it on and people say WOW that is SOO YOU!
Are you looking for more fitted with a dramatic etheral feeling like the lace dress? OR were you going for a fuller really dramatic dress like the Maggie?
Also keep in mind when your wedding is because I can bet that Maggie dress is a heavy dress but that lace one is very light. THAT played a MAJOR role in my dress decision making process =)

HTH

IMO, I like the style of the 1st dress, I think its REALLY pretty and from a bride who had a fitted gown like that it was awesome because I danced my butt off at the wedding and my dress was light and summery.
I LOVE the top of the Maggie dress, just not as crazy about the bottom of it... Its a really pretty dress but something about the bottom doesnt make me LOVE it... JMO =)

they are both beautiful but my vote is the maggie but i am more traditional - princessy - cinderellaish

keep shopping!

Thanks girls.

I have until tomorrow to decide...the second dress does weighs a lot, so that is something that may determine which dress i'll be wearing.

They are so different! It's hard for me to compare.
Do you 'envision' yourself in one over the other?