Foot Spa Question, any Suggestions?

FH wants a footspa for Christmas. I've been doing some research online and have been getting conflicting messages.

I've narrowed it down to:

WATERPIK FS-021W REFLEXOLOGY FOOT SPA

and

WaterPik Pedicure Foot Spa FS-015

I originally liked the Conair, but have been hearing bad things.

Do any of you girls have one & if so does it massage nicely, water stay warm, feel good?

Thanks.