My friend waitresses at Legal Seafood right by the Walt Whitman Mall. I always hear people raving about that place, but I HATE HATE HATE seafood, so I have no firsthand experience.
There's always Red Lobster!!! (LoL- )
usuk2004
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Where are you?
There's the Sea Basin in Rocky Point and Lobster Roll out in Riverhead/Calverton area.
And then there's Land and Sea in Mt Sinai...the place has zero atmosphere, but it's so good! They have a lobster bake special where you get a big bowl of mussels in garlic and white wine, and a boiled lobster with corn on the cob and pasta or potato all for $12.95. It's so simple and so good!!! They have other stuff too, but i always get the lobster
The Steam Room or Docksides in Port Jeff.
MrsERod
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
definitely NOT H2O in Smithtown!
StepherG
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by shorty the pumpkin
My friend waitresses at Legal Seafood right by the Walt Whitman Mall. I always hear people raving about that place, but I HATE HATE HATE seafood, so I have no firsthand experience.
There's always Red Lobster!!! (LoL- )
NO Red Lobster
DCSAAB06
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
I heard Legal Seafood by Roosevelt Field.
I havent tried it myself since Im not big on seafood.
Shorty McBride
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by StepherG
Posted by shorty the pumpkin
My friend waitresses at Legal Seafood right by the Walt Whitman Mall. I always hear people raving about that place, but I HATE HATE HATE seafood, so I have no firsthand experience.
There's always Red Lobster!!! (LoL- )
NO Red Lobster
OMG I was totally kidding I was hoping you'd get that!!!
StepherG
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
I don't like Land & Sea in Mt. Sinai (they have fly paper with dead flys hanging from the ceiling- GROSS)...and the Dockside really isnt very good anymore...I used to like them...
I'm out east at exit 66...but it's my birthday so we're willing to travel! Thanks for all the ideas!!
Shorty McBride
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
How about Georgio's?
sophie78
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
The two best seafood restaurants are:
Riverbay in Williston Park and The Jolly Fisherman in Roslyn
Preshy7
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by am470
The two best seafood restaurants are:
Riverbay in Williston Park and The Jolly Fisherman in Roslyn
riverbay is good
a less known is Canterbury Ales in Oyster bay- good prices and 70 beers by the glass.
nylisa
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by diamondgrlie
I love the Schooner on the Nautical Mile.
me too
darly
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Jolly Fisherman is my in-laws diner...we used to go there every Fri. night for a long time...the lobsters are great -- Be prepared for an older crowd but the food is consistent and always good...
Southside in Lindenhurst if you like to get into your food
Rob-luvs-me
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Riverbay is going to be your best bet. Legal Seafood at Roosevelt field is pretty good - not quite as good as Riverbay though. Jolly fisherman is also good.
Coolfish has some great seafood on their menu as well.
steflily
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Popeis Clam Bar in Wantagh on Wantagh Ave. They might be a chain and also in Coram, Smithtown and Sayville. Absolutely the best seafood ever. Better than Legal Seafood I think.
MrsTC
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Tons of places out in the Hamptons....in Montauk, Sag Harbor.
nylisa
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by MrsTC
Tons of places out in the Hamptons....in Montauk, Sag Harbor.
That is correct.
dkwife
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by am470
The two best seafood restaurants are:
Riverbay in Williston Park and The Jolly Fisherman in Roslyn
I agree on the Jolly, I personally have had more than one bad meal at Riverbay.
darly
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Ask for Edgar the waiter at Jolly - he's the BEST!!
