I grew up in Maine where we never had a shortage of good seafood restaurants. I find that LI has very few GOOD ones. Can you recommend any?
Karacg
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
My FAVORITE FAVORITE is Stillwaters, in Seaford. Prices are great, food is really excellent. Not fancy, but it is on the water and the food is excellent (did I say that already??).
Riverbay and Legal Seafood are good too, but I still haven't found anything worthwhile in Freeport.
jcndd
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
I am not a seafood fan, by my girlfriend is and SWEARS by Legal Seafood in Huntington. And the restaurant itself is really beautiful and clean!
Happy Birthday Steph!
divabride
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
If your on the northshore, try Louie's in Port Washington. They have exceptional seafood and they were featured in 'meet the parents'.
darly
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Rachel's in Freeport is really yummy
VickiC
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by Karacg
My FAVORITE FAVORITE is Stillwaters, in Seaford. Prices are great, food is really excellent. Not fancy, but it is on the water and the food is excellent (did I say that already??).
I'm glad to hear you say that! I know the chef there very well (he's my cousin! )
It's also one of my favorites.
computergirl
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
I like the Bedlam St Fish Company in Cold Spring Harbor.
Karacg
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by VickiC
Posted by Karacg
My FAVORITE FAVORITE is Stillwaters, in Seaford. Prices are great, food is really excellent. Not fancy, but it is on the water and the food is excellent (did I say that already??).
I'm glad to hear you say that! I know the chef there very well (he's my cousin! )
It's also one of my favorites.
That's so cool --- can you put in a good word for me??
As soon as I get off bed rest, that is the FIRST place I am heading!!
wood2be
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Gosmans if you are out in Montauk or Bostwicks in East Hampton. No one had Lobster as good as the ones in Maine though
Stefanie
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
I like Schooner in Freeport and Steve's Pier One in Bayville. It's so nice there and you can eat outside on the deck in the summertime. It's right on the water.
Preshy7
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by computergirl
I like the Bedlam St Fish Company in Cold Spring Harbor.
me too!
kdelace
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Fisherman's Catch in Pt. Lookout is great.. great atmosphere also- right onthe water and outdoor area...
Cindy
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by MrsERod
definitely NOT H2O in Smithtown!
How funny you say this. I was just there last week. Not only was the place crazy overpriced, but I did not enjoy the food at all. People rave about it and I don't know why.
There's the Sea Basin in Rocky Point and Lobster Roll out in Riverhead/Calverton area.
And then there's Land and Sea in Mt Sinai...the place has zero atmosphere, but it's so good! They have a lobster bake special where you get a big bowl of mussels in garlic and white wine, and a boiled lobster with corn on the cob and pasta or potato all for $12.95. It's so simple and so good!!! They have other stuff too, but i always get the lobster
The Steam Room or Docksides in Port Jeff.
I enjoy Sea Basin also
Jenny5150
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by Preshy7
Posted by computergirl
I like the Bedlam St Fish Company in Cold Spring Harbor.
If you're looking for a very casual place, The Fort Hill Fish Market has good seafood (it's a BYOB though!)
February05
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
Posted by usuk2004 The Steam Room in Port Jeff.
i LOVE the steamroom!!! they have the BEST lobster bisque.. and Bread bowls!!! ya can't go wrong with bread bowls!
juju
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
I still have not found a good seafood restaurant on Long Island and I have been to most of the ones mentioned on this thread. However, I do find Legal Seafood to be decent.
designerbride
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
I LOVE Blue Honu in Huntington, a haiwaiian vibe, but not cheesy at all. The Lobster tails are as big as my arm, no joke! Plus they have killer coconut martinis.
FTRBRIDE
Posted:
Member since
Re: Good Seafood Restaurants on Long Island?
It's not a 'fish' restaurant, it's a french restaurant, but 99% of their entrees are fish. The menu is different everyday depending on what kind of fish they get that morning. It is absolutely amazing- Kitchen A Bistro in Saint James. (Don't expect anything fancy, it's a small french bistro).
