Help! - Churches Out East

Fh and I are getting married at East Wind. We are trying to find a Church that is close to Wading River to marry us. Im not Catholic so I need a Protestant Church- any denomination is fine. I'm finding that the really nice churches all seem to be Roman Catholic which wont work. Anyone know of decent looking Protestant Churches out East?? Or have any opinion on the two that Ive found so far?

Middle Island Presbyterian Church
Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church in Rocky Point