honeymoon caribbean help

Hi Ladies,
so i need help deciding where to go for our honeymoon
we want to to go to the caribbean but just somewhere we have not been before

we were thingking of st. lucia, st. thomas, aruba or bahamas. We prefer an all inclusive resort as we are on a budget & everything i find is too expensive and not all inclusive..
so if anyone has been to any places/has any tips or advice i'd greatly appreciate it !
this is something i want to decide and get out of the way so i can cross of my list of a million TO DO's

TIA

i went to all of those place you listed...

I love the bahamas but its more for families (unless you stay at a couples only resort)

The other 3 are more honeymoon spots especially aruba and st. lucia. in aruba you can actually leave the resort and wander around and there is a big night life!!!