If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
Xelindrya
Posted:
Member since
If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
Ok, first off I have to say WHY I was there. We went to Lindenhurst to see In & Out travel about our Honeymoon. It was early so we decided we’d do lunch after. We asked Dave to head us to a local food joint. He said ‘if you don’t mind diners I know one’ and Im thinking Fries and Hamburgers, no biggie, sure. He sent us over the Sunrise Hwy (I can’t remember the exact directions). We ended up in front of the Babylon Town Hall.
I ordered the Salmon Luigi (I think that’s what it was called) kinda risky at $16.99 for a DINER Salmon but I was hungry. Jim got a Gyro and played it safe.
OH MY GOD My salmon came and this thing was huge!! And COVERED in Garlic Cloves that were perfectly cooked to explode with flavor and not acid like garlic. This thing sat on top of Asparagus and carrots and spinach with two huge broccoli sprouts on the sides with a twice baked chive spiced potato. It was WONDERFUL! I couldn’t believe how good it was. The tastes were nicely balanced and the serving was so much I took half home.
Jim’s Gyro he could barely finish (which is RARE, he can EAT) he didn’t get to finish his fries, which were also good.
We had Cream of Turkey Soup and him had a Greek salad to start. Jim doesn’t like greek salads but he said this one was wonderful. I loved that turkey soup. It was TASTY!
Ok.. so all this for like $30.
No way this can be true. So give me the dirt.. this place is rat infested or something? No way that a ‘diner’ can have such great food like that and not have a problem, right?
Lisa Rose
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
there are some really good diners on LI!!
try the one in West Islip on Montauk Hyway....Delphi diner!! YUMMY!!!
Stacey1403
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
That is one of the best diner's on LI IMHO!!!
I spent many a late night there,with my friends when I was young and single
nj42305
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
I LOVE the diner across from Babylon Town Hall.
sandj100304
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
That is the best diner! We go there a lot for all the reasons you mention! Love that place!
Kate
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
Most good diners are well kept secrets. Alot of people don't think outside grilled cheese and burgers, or a breakfast of fries with gravy after a rough night at 4am
You'd be surprised at some of the enormous delicious dinners served up at diners.
Xelindrya
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
Jim & I couldnt stop gawking at the food. We kept on and on about how good everything was.. 'here taste this.. taste it like this... oooh try the browned garlic with the salmon'
At the end we just said 'This place is worth the drive' and for us that's pretty high marks.
What was the name again? Anyone?
sandj100304
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
South Bay Diner
Xelindrya
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
Posted by sandj100304
South Bay Diner
YES!! THANK YOU!!
swags1016
Posted:
Member since
x
NYCHICK
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
I need an address to this diner please
MrsBtoBe2005
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
We also love the South Bay diner. The food there is great and they serve generous portions. The address is 185 Sunrise Hwy. in Lindenhurst.
I also agree with the Delphi diner in West Islip! It's another one of our favorites.
Jenn P
Posted:
Member since
Re: If you've been to the diner across the Street from Babylon Town Hall, I need your reviews.. I went and....
My girlfriend and I meet there for dinner occasionally. The food is VERY good. I think of it more as a restaurant than a diner. It's a little pricey but I don't go out to eat often so I don't mind.