Post New Topic

Is this completely wrong of me?

Original post by lreigada

OK - I obviously feel bad about my thoughts or else I would not post - so please provide objective advice.

I have 4 BM - 3 of them are out of town and 1 lives locally. Now 3 of them have been working for months on my bridal shower and bachelor party, and I have heard that one of the girls never responds to any of the emails ever. So I have tried to chat with her about this, but in her defense she did not care for all these deatils at her wedding. Also, she is not planning on coming to my bridal shower or bachelorette party b/c she lives out of town and has a 1 year old baby so I think she does not feel invested to plan. I guess that is besides the point, what is the point is that the other 3 girls have worked really hard and are splitting the costs of the events with no support of the 4th bridesmaid. I was thing as a gift I would offer to pay for either their hair or make-up for all of their efforts planning this weekend extravaganza - do you think I am being fair to the 4th girl?
bride2b24 Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?

i dont think its wrong......obviously all of the little things that matter to you dont matter to her so im sure she wouldnt care about hair and makeup either!

CLMon7906 Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?


Posted by VadersBride2006


Posted by marymoon

I think what you're doing is fine. You're thanking them specficially for their efforts, which she did not put in. Or to just be the better person, pay for it for all the BMs and let them know it's to thank them for all of their help. That way she's the one who will know you're being kind to her even thought she couldn't be bothered.



I agree, maybe you could do a little something extra as a gift for the other 3, but not something as blatanly obvious as 'We're all getting our hair done and you're not'



i agree
mskittynj Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?


Posted by eden

I don't see anything wrong with hair and makeup for the 3, but not the one. If that one girl can't be bothered to help out, then she shouldn't get financial help from you.

I have 3 girls and only 1 is helping me much so I'm paying for her hair and makeup, while hte other two will have pay for one or the other. And I'm also buying all their dresses and a gift for all of them.

Sometimes you want to be fair, but being fair to all is NOT being fair to the 3 girls who helped you the most. They are doing al the work so reward them accordingly.




I agree with you!!!! The 4th girl should help because she cares about you and your day! Why should she be rewarded for doing nothing?
XOXOXO
Kitty
Kitty
LBride Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?

Obviously you picked this person to be a BM because they have impacted your life and mean something to you. But it's not like she would know if you paid for the other 3 and not her if that's what you want to do. I am a MOH for my sister and I can't tell you how annoying all the bridal party emails are back and forth, I don't respond to half of them. Doesn't mean I don't love my sister or care about her or her wedding, some people have other things going on other than your wedding.

kam29 Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?

What it comes down to is the 4th may feel slighted and hurt that you are doing something for 3 and not all 4 of the BM's.

Is the extra money really worth hurting the one BM?

If you do something extra special for the other 3, make sure that the 4th doesn't find out.
waterspout4 Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?


Posted by aliwnec10


Posted by VadersBride2006

I love my BM's and most of them i've been friends with for many many years. But i cannot afford to shell out $150 for this ones dress, $60 for this ones hair, or anything else because all those things add up. Now if your parents are paying for the wedding... than okay. It wouldn't be a big deal to pay for this or that to have them in your wedding party. JMO. Did that make sense?



You make sense, but I am assuming that this was written toward me, so I feel the need to respond. I also paid for my own wedding. But in the 18 months of the wedding plans, some of the girls found themselves in different financial situations. One got laid off, another needed repairs to her house and had a child entering college as a single mother. Things change, but I didn't want the bridal party to change.

I wasn't jumping for joy when I needed to shell out a few extra hundred dollars for them to be there, but in the grand scheme of things, what's $250 added to your total bill of thousands? So, I worked a few extra shifts at my second job. To have my BM there was worth a few days of work.
aliwnec10 Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?


Posted by waterspout4


Posted by aliwnec10


Posted by VadersBride2006

I love my BM's and most of them i've been friends with for many many years. But i cannot afford to shell out $150 for this ones dress, $60 for this ones hair, or anything else because all those things add up. Now if your parents are paying for the wedding... than okay. It wouldn't be a big deal to pay for this or that to have them in your wedding party. JMO. Did that make sense?



You make sense, but I am assuming that this was written toward me, so I feel the need to respond. I also paid for my own wedding. But in the 18 months of the wedding plans, some of the girls found themselves in different financial situations. One got laid off, another needed repairs to her house and had a child entering college as a single mother. Things change, but I didn't want the bridal party to change.

I wasn't jumping for joy when I needed to shell out a few extra hundred dollars for them to be there, but in the grand scheme of things, what's $250 added to your total bill of thousands? So, I worked a few extra shifts at my second job. To have my BM there was worth a few days of work.



I realize that it's not a large amount of money. But my FH and i are also building a house at the moment, so literally... EVERY PENNY COUNTS right now. But that's my circumstances right now and everyone is different. But you're right. It's not too much money and normally it would be no problem. But there are some people that are not in a position to shell out $250. I'm just saying... that's all.
rlgirl Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?

i think what you have decided to do is fine. i dont think it would be fair to the other 3 girls if you rewarded the 4th when she hasnt done anything.

waterspout4 Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?


Posted by aliwnec10


Posted by waterspout4


Posted by aliwnec10


Posted by VadersBride2006

I love my BM's and most of them i've been friends with for many many years. But i cannot afford to shell out $150 for this ones dress, $60 for this ones hair, or anything else because all those things add up. Now if your parents are paying for the wedding... than okay. It wouldn't be a big deal to pay for this or that to have them in your wedding party. JMO. Did that make sense?



You make sense, but I am assuming that this was written toward me, so I feel the need to respond. I also paid for my own wedding. But in the 18 months of the wedding plans, some of the girls found themselves in different financial situations. One got laid off, another needed repairs to her house and had a child entering college as a single mother. Things change, but I didn't want the bridal party to change.

I wasn't jumping for joy when I needed to shell out a few extra hundred dollars for them to be there, but in the grand scheme of things, what's $250 added to your total bill of thousands? So, I worked a few extra shifts at my second job. To have my BM there was worth a few days of work.



I realize that it's not a large amount of money. But my FH and i are also building a house at the moment, so literally... EVERY PENNY COUNTS right now. But that's my circumstances right now and everyone is different. But you're right. It's not too much money and normally it would be no problem. But there are some people that are not in a position to shell out $250. I'm just saying... that's all.



I completely understand. I just hope that people can understand why I did what I did.

Let's all just
aliwnec10 Posted:

Re: Is this completely wrong of me?


Posted by waterspout4


Posted by aliwnec10


Posted by waterspout4


Posted by aliwnec10


Posted by VadersBride2006

I love my BM's and most of them i've been friends with for many many years. But i cannot afford to shell out $150 for this ones dress, $60 for this ones hair, or anything else because all those things add up. Now if your parents are paying for the wedding... than okay. It wouldn't be a big deal to pay for this or that to have them in your wedding party. JMO. Did that make sense?



You make sense, but I am assuming that this was written toward me, so I feel the need to respond. I also paid for my own wedding. But in the 18 months of the wedding plans, some of the girls found themselves in different financial situations. One got laid off, another needed repairs to her house and had a child entering college as a single mother. Things change, but I didn't want the bridal party to change.

I wasn't jumping for joy when I needed to shell out a few extra hundred dollars for them to be there, but in the grand scheme of things, what's $250 added to your total bill of thousands? So, I worked a few extra shifts at my second job. To have my BM there was worth a few days of work.



I realize that it's not a large amount of money. But my FH and i are also building a house at the moment, so literally... EVERY PENNY COUNTS right now. But that's my circumstances right now and everyone is different. But you're right. It's not too much money and normally it would be no problem. But there are some people that are not in a position to shell out $250. I'm just saying... that's all.



I completely understand. I just hope that people can understand why I did what I did.

Let's all just



I understand completely. I was just trying to say that everyone has different circumstances.

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.