My fiance and I FINALLY booked our venue after visiting what seemed like hundreds of venues on Long Island and a few in the city and Brooklyn. I figured I'd save you some leg work and report the price quotes we got for 2012.
Prices per person, excluding tax and service charges.
(ceremony site fee = $750++) Friday night 6:30-12 (or 7-12 without ceremony) March $71 April $93 May $98 June-Sept $105 Good Friday = $72
Saturday afternoon 12:30-6 (or 1-6...) March $66 April $79 May $86 June-Sept $90
Saturday night 6:30-11:30 (no ceremony) March $83 April $102 May $110 June-Sept $115
Sunday afternoon 12-5:30 (or 12:30-5:30...) March $64 April $74 May $82 June-Sept $86 May 13 = $74
Sunday evening 6-11 (no ceremony) March $66 April $75 May $90 June-Sept $90 May 13 = $77
(Ceremony fee = $700++) May Saturday night 200 person min. $118 Saturday afternoon 175 min. $89 Friday night 175 min. $102