Narrowed it down to 2!

I have been positing about hotel blocks and narrowed it down to 2: holiday inn in plainview or hilton garden inn Melville.
Any good or bad experiences/stays with either?
We are havig many oot guests and it was very important to me and the fh that our guests who have flown in are comfortable.

Both are same price. Both have a bar that will be open on site. And both comp the bridal suite with the same number of rooms booked.
What do you suggest?

Narrowed it down to 2!

I saw holiday inn today they were so nice. Their shuttle is a little small.... But you are close enough for it not to matter. I thought it was a great place.

Narrowed it down to 2!

We did the holiday! Nice rooms and the hotel inside is nice...however there were a few things i did not like...the front desk forgot to give out two of my guest their gift bag...i had to call and remind them. the day of the wedding i had their shuttle service call me to tell me there was a fee...I had my coordinators go back and forth with the hotel to figure out the problem because the hotel had included it in my contract! Poor communication towards the end though...