Post New Topic

Need Opinion

coldasice217 Posted:

Need Opinion

I mentioned this briefly on Friday after it happened, but it seemed to get lost in the shuffle, and since it seems that there's more people around today, I would really appreciate your honest opinions on this.

I went to order the BM dresses with my two friends on Friday. I have been in contact with my entire BP via email throughout the whole dress ordeal, because we were entertaining various options to get the dress at a lower price, but ultimately decided it was easier and safer to just go to the store. So I told the girls in the email the price of the dress that I was able to get for them, and everyone was ok with that price.

So we went, and one friend is small, and one friend is bigger. I had a bad feeling that my one friend would need to pay the extra fee for plus size, and unfortunately, that's what happened. Which I think is bs, because Jim Hjelm runs so small that almost EVERYONE of a normal size falls into their plus size category. Like really? a 16 is plus size? Cuz that's what their cutoff is

So the woman at the store rings them up, says to my one friend your dress comes out to X, and to my other friend your dress comes out to X+60. I wanted to crawl under the table, and my friend clearly was really embarrassed about it, so I tried to talk to the saleswoman, but she said there was nothing she can do. I said I was sorry to my friend, and she said it was ok, and just paid her deposit.

So we got back in the car, I drove with my other friend, who told me that I should tell my friend that she doesn't need to bring a gift to the shower, or that I should pay the fee for her, because it wasn't fair that she's the only person that needs to pay that much more.

My mother and sister agreed...said that I should pay the fee for her.

FH is a bastid, and said it's not our responsibility, and if she's bigger, then she should have to pay more because she's still getting the same value as the other girls dollars vs. material needed. Spoken like a true man

I'm stuck between a rock and a hard place now...part of me is angry and upset and embarrassed, and feels that since I told her it was going to be one price and it ended up being more, I should pay the difference. But then the other part of me feels that I shouldn't, partly because it might be insulting and single her out further to pay for part of her dress or have her be the only one showing up empty handed to the shower, and partly because it's the responsibility of the BP to pay for their dresses.

So I guess all I'm asking is, what would you do if you were in the same position? Like, what would you REALLY do? I know that the right thing to do is probably pay the difference, but money is also very tight and the 60 will make a difference to me, believe it or not. I'm just so torn and feel really bad

TIA.
FuTuRe MrS MaZz Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

Im also the type to completely agree with your FH... if she needs extra material, it isnt your fault and thus, you shouldnt have to pay the difference...

Debrian2009 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

It's tough situation; but at the same time, if she is that much bigger than everyone else, she should have assumed it may cost more for the dress.

Sort of like if someone was taller and had to buy a longer gown than an average person; she would have to pay more.

Did she complain about the 60 bucks? If she's not making an issue out of it, I wouldn't.

In my opinion, when people accept an invite into a bridal party, they should expect the cost of things as well...you did great trying to find a cheaper price for the girls as I would do the same.

Good luck!
BarbieGrl10 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

OK... I'm not saying you're being like this but its what I think if when I read this post.

Remember the bridezilla that bought her friend a new dress b.c she gained some weight? And the friend got really upset about it?

Thats what I think of. If it happened to me I wouldnt want anyone to make a big deal over it...I would get more embarrassed.

I wouldnt address it any further with her b/c I'm sure shes feeling sh!tty about it and for you to 'throw' or 'offer' money for the 'problem' makes it worse. Its not about being cheap. Its just about letting it go. It ***** for her but just leave it be.

ETA: Did that sound b!tchy? Cause I didnt mean it to!
Lisa909 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion


Posted by BarbieGrl10

OK... I'm not saying you're being like this but its what I think if when I read this post.

Remember the bridezilla that bought her friend a new dress b.c she gained some weight? And the friend got really upset about it?

Thats what I think of. If it happened to me I would want anyone to make a big deal over it...I would get more embarrassed.

I wouldnt address it any further with her b/c I'm sure shes feeling sh!tty about it and for you to 'throw' or 'offer' money for the 'problem' makes it worse. Its not about being cheap. Its just about letting it go. It ***** for her but just leave it be.



ITA
gina409 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

ali i am in a wedding in nov..i just got the dresses and i had to pay extra 40 at rk bridal cause i had to get it ina 16..noone offered to pay it,and i didnt expect anybody to,i paid for my size cause its my size and that was end of story..i understand u feel bad but i dont think u should have to pay...and to be honest if she expects u to pay thats pretty crappy imo..

xosweetiexo Posted:

Re: Need Opinion


Posted by BarbieGrl10

OK... I'm not saying you're being like this but its what I think if when I read this post.

Remember the bridezilla that bought her friend a new dress b.c she gained some weight? And the friend got really upset about it?

Thats what I think of. If it happened to me I would want anyone to make a big deal over it...I would get more embarrassed.

I wouldnt address it any further with her b/c I'm sure shes feeling sh!tty about it and for you to 'throw' or 'offer' money for the 'problem' makes it worse. Its not about being cheap. Its just about letting it go. It ***** for her but just leave it be.

ETA: Did that sound b!tchy? Cause I didnt mean it to!




I totally agree! My BM is also paying more for her dress b/c she needed a bigger size. I really dont have the extra money to be throwing around- so I just didnt mention it again. It stinks- but I had to pay extra for another friends wedding bc I also needed extra material for my big boobs, and of course I b*tched and moaned about it... but I didnt expect the bride to pay for it. I paid for it myself... its not the brides fault that the material is extra. I would just let it go bc you dont want her to feel more embarrased than she prob. already is.
MLAngelo Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

I probably wouldn't pay it, but I understand why you would feel you should.

ttdiff11 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion



i was a bm last april and there were 2 plus size girls who had to pay more, they paid themselves.....
azailia Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

I have been in bp's where I had to get a 'plus' size and i paid for it. it wasn't even an issue.

That's just part of the deal...sorry

my girls ordered up to an 18 and they had no plus size fee. the designer was alyce. we lucked out!!
ace730 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

I am actually in the same situation. We are ordering from Jim Hjelm and 3 of my bridesmaids are 5'9 and above so they need to order extra length (which is $20 more) and two need to order a size 18, which is $30 more. Honestly, I know it ***** but I agree with Barbiegirl, especially in reference to the plus size girls. By offering to pay the extra it only draws more attention to the situation, which will be more embaressing for the girl. Just let it go and if anything, maybe give her something a little extra as a bm gift. I feel bad as well, and the situation is uncomfortable, but it really isn't your responsibility to pick up the extra cost.

AugustBridein09 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion


Posted by FuTuRe MrS MaZz

Im also the type to completely agree with your FH... if she needs extra material, it isnt your fault and thus, you shouldnt have to pay the difference...





I agree.
FutureSMwifey Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

I am like you because I would feel bad as well...but it is also like girls who need to pay a lot of money for alterations... I think it just comes with the job.. I think by telling her not to bring you a gift is more then nice of you. I don't think you should pay the difference. Hopefully she won;t need much alterations and if your other girls pay alterations it will kind of balance out..

trust me i totally feel you bc i would be stressing about it to and feel awful. But honestly it isn't your fault and I think by telling her not to give u a gift was more then most would do..


good luck
michelle1024 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

That really *****, mostly that it happened in front of everyone, but I agree with the other girls, at this point bringing attention to the extra money spent might just make her feel bad. I would just leave it alone.

Celeste617 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

I understand that you are feeling bad for the girl, but if your BM isn't making a fuss about it, I'd just let it go. I think the saleslady could have handled it in a more subtle way, however
SoontobeMrsG Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

I can understand how you feel. In saying that , when your friends agree to be in your bridal party they understand the costs associated with this.
My sister who is my MOH had to pay extra because she is tall. Do I think this is fair? Absolutely not! Do short people get a discount? Do thin brides get a discount? Of course not!
So I asked the sales lady if they can waive this fee for extra length being that I am purchasing my gown from them as well and what she did was split the cost.
Maybe you can call the place and maybe they can split the charge for the plus size or discount her alterations, if she has paid for the dress. I would not tell your friend that you are doing this just in case they do say No. I would then drop the subject because your friend my already be a bit embarrassed.
Good luck.
Deeglasser Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

i have ALWAYS had to pay more for a BM dress b/c i'm a larger lady myself... brides have never offered to pay the difference, and i have never expected them to! i'm sure if you offered she wouldn't take it. and truthfully, $60 is A LOT for a larger size, i've only ever paid about $20 extra!

Deeglasser Posted:

Re: Need Opinion


Posted by Celeste617

I understand that you are feeling bad for the girl, but if your BM isn't making a fuss about it, I'd just let it go. I think the saleslady could have handled it in a more subtle way, however



yes, i agree. i wouldn't appreciate it if she announced it for everyone to hear. it's really no one's business...
EmiNoa628 Posted:

Re: Need Opinion


Posted by FuTuRe MrS MaZz

Im also the type to completely agree with your FH... if she needs extra material, it isnt your fault and thus, you shouldnt have to pay the difference...



I totally agree with FH..( That is one of the reasons I cut all BM's) I had 2 oversize and then decided to just do Junior BM and FG..

But to be nice youcan go half with her... Put don't stress yourself over that.. Its not your fault she is a bigger girl..
dedecakes Posted:

Re: Need Opinion

I agree with FH, too. Don't get me wrong...I would feel bad, but you have enough expenses. If she agreed to be in your wedding party, I'm sure she knew she would have to spend X amt. of money on BM odds and ends.

I just got my BMs dresses. (Bill Levkoff, I know you saw the pictures b/c you commented on my post.) His dresses run very small, too. My MOH is normally a 00 and they wanted her to get a size 6!!! She ended up getting the 4. And all of my BMs measurement ran them a size larger than they usually are. My bridal consultant said that the alternations could run them up to 95 dollars.
I really hope not because I will feel terrible! :(

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.