We were looking into this for a friend's BP - here's a list I threw together (no making fun! I'm super anal when it come to organizing
![]()
). Most of this is just copied and pasted from these web-sites:
http://www.fireisland.com/accomodations.htm
http://www.fireislandcc.org/oceanbch.html
Some of the prices might be outdated, but I know the Palms is current for off season.
Cleggs Hotel
478 Bayberry Walk
(631) 583-5399
Email:
[email protected]Website: http://cleggshotel.com
Cleggs caters to a family clientele and children under 10 stay free. Rates are extremely reasonable by island standards. The place is a bit simple and clean. Except for the few studios all rooms share communal bathrooms.
The building was Built in 1943. Clegg's Hotel resembles a sailor's rooming house with a country blue décor. Centered in the heart of Ocean Beach, 100 feet from the Great South Bay and a five-minute walk to the Atlantic Ocean.
The fully air conditioned hotel offers two unique accommodations:
Studio apartments with either a view of the Great South Bay or garden view, private bath, a kitchenette and one full sized bed. The units can sleep a family of four. The guest rooms have a European style design with one full size bed or two twin beds. Guest Rooms share the use of four private skylight bathrooms on the floor.
For rates and more information click here.
Fours Seasons Bed & Breakfast
468 Dehnhoff Walk
http://www.fivacations.com/
(631) 583-8295, talked to Jane, call Harvey and leave a message
Wedding for apartments
Seven bedrooms with shared baths. There is an emphasis on healthful, natural foods and cooking. Breakfast includes fresh- squeezed orange juice, homemade muffins, lox, bagels, cream cheese, eggs and omelets. Afternoon tea, at 4, includes a light meal of salads, pizza, pasta and sandwiches. Saturdays, they throw a barbecue of salmon, london broil, hamburgers and more. Young children are not permitted here.
Open year round. Summer season: mid-May through mid-September. Two-day stay required on weekends. $300 for Friday and Saturday nights, double occupancy with shared bath, includes breakfast and afternoon tea. Sundays through Thursdays, $125 for the first night, $100 for each night thereafter. Children over 12 welcome; add $25 a child. Off season: $250 for two-night weekend stay; $125 for Saturday night only; $100 for other days. Labor Day weekend package for two; $600 for Friday through Sunday nights.
Apartments
15 bed within 7 bedrooms, could also use cots
Houser's Hotel
785 Evergreen Walk
(631) 583-8900
Hotel reserved for wedding that weekend
Open since 1921 this is the oldest hotel on the island. Don’t expect to find many amenities, however. If you’re looking for more than air conditioning, ceiling fans and color TV, this is not your gig.
Open May 1 through September. Daily rates based on double occupancy with shared shower: Fridays and Saturdays, $75 a person; Sundays through Thursdays, $50 a person for one night, $40 a person for more than one night. Weekdays, half-price for children.
Place In The Sun
987 Surfview Walk
(631) 583-5716
Open May through October. Two-night minimum stay on Friday and Saturday nights: double occupancy with shared bath, $250. Sundays through Thursdays, $75 a night. Children over 8 welcome on weekdays. Labor Day weekend package for two: $425 for Friday through Sunday nights.
The Palms
(631) 583-8870
www.thepalmsatoceanbeach.com
2 of the 3 bedroom apartments are still available
3 Bedroom Apartments (3) - $600 per night
20 Hotel Rooms - $200 least expensive, but the bathroom is in the hallway
2 room suite - $325