As to 2 photogs some of the philosophy is that if you have a large number of guests, having 2 will help to get different shots of diff people and if you have a small wedding 1 should be able to handle it.
I have seen a lot of threads here where girls say it's what you want and size of wedding doesn't matter. Part of that is because w 2 photogs you usually get 1 who is traditional wedding photog - - who may also do photojournalistic style but still captures all the traditional shots. and the 2nd does the artsy ones. also a 2nd cvan be in a diff place getting completely diff shots or just diff angles on the same poses.
I had a 2nd for 4 hrs for getting ready, ceremony and CH. With that I got a combo of diff people, diff angles and little diff stle. and I had small wedding but chose 1.5 photog
and part of the decision is cost. I think ave for 2nd is about $1000 for the day.
Now as for Patken, we weren't thrilled with them because they said they would choose the photog you get not you getting the one you like. maybe you could argue that but we also didn't like that they held the proof dvd 6 mos, maybe a year before you got it for your own use.
The place we finally selected (SilverFox) gave us the prints and dvd about 5 weeks after the wedding. print away, do what you want - - we made 4x6 prints at CVS and DYI cards as thank you's that way.
So if dvd of proofs is important to you be sure you ask how the photog company handles that. One we checked would not release them at all and some only did if you spent enuf $$ on an album.
as to the person you checked besides Patken, did you look at albums of his work and like his style?.
that's an important item. and check BBB for any issues. You might also ask him for references and see his reaction.
Prices we got for 1 photog and album of maybe 40 pics was betw $2500 and $4000. those were Nov of 2006.
again we were happy with our place and thought they were the most flexible and reasonable. $1500 for photog and dvd proofs (and prints - - now they charge for printed proofs).
album is 80 images for $1100. again these are 2006 prices not sure whaT album prices are today.
prices I've included are not bells & whistles prices but got the job done.
As to style, again I think that's what you like best. we are getting magazize stle since it gives more design options.
HTH