Pick our 1st dance song!

FH and I can not decide what we want to do!!! 'Our' songs don't really work as first dance songs and we have complete opposite tastes in music. (Which is mucho fun for our DJ)

We have a dance lesson tomorrow and have to pick so she can choreograph it.

This is the one that we (well, I) had picked originally. I love it. Love the dance. FH loves that I love it. lol

Here's a visual: So Close First Dance


or


we could do this song FH loves and I like as well. I'm just not sure what type of choreography she would do for it:

Old Fashioned

FH says he wants me to pick and would be happy either way.
Help!