POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

LuvMyAlfonse Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:48 AM

POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

Guestbook would have pics of us throughout our relationship:

Vase:

dream426 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:50 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

I like the photo album. The vase is cute though.

AMGBride2008 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:53 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

Jenn, I'm confused
Help a blonde girl out... whatcha mean???

LuvMyAlfonse Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:55 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

people would either sign the photo album around our pictures or would sign the vase - instead of a traditional guestbook...

wwyd?

AMGBride2008 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:56 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

Photo album... I really like the vase, but I feel like people would have a hard time signing it and everyone's little messages wouldn't fit.

LuvMyAlfonse Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:57 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

you don't think the photo album is too narcissistic?

korndoggie Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:58 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

I like the photo album.

The vase seems like it could get a little clumsy while signing it. Knowing my family it would end up on the floor in a million pieces. It's adorable though. They do make those plates that you can sign, it's the same idea just flatter.

korndoggie Posted: Apr 17, 2007 08:59 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

Posted by LuvMyAlfonse

you don't think the photo album is too narcissistic?

Too narcissistic? No. It's your wedding, your guests are there to celebrate you guys!!!

laural2979 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 09:14 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

I made a photo guest book on MyPublisher.com. Pics are in my album. It came out really nice and it was pretty cheap too.

NicoleRN76 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 09:23 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

I like the photobook idea. Would you put all random pics of the 2 of you in or would you go in chronological order from past to present? I was thinking of the photobook too...

blu6385 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 09:27 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

i voted for the photo album ... but i may be a little biased cause i am going to do a photo guest book but i was thiking of getting it from picaboo.com ... maybe ill look into shutterfly ...

blu6385 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 09:29 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

Posted by LuvMyAlfonse

people would either sign the photo album around our pictures or would sign the vase - instead of a traditional guestbook...

wwyd?

just so you know if you want more room for people to sign you can have one page blank and the other page with pictures .... check out picaboo.com you can see what i am talking about ...

AMGBride2008 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 09:30 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

Posted by LuvMyAlfonse

you don't think the photo album is too narcissistic?

Not at all... I know I would love to look at pics of the bride and groom thru out their relationship.

soon2bmrsdunn Posted: Apr 17, 2007 09:35 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

I voted for the photo album!

TnOiOnL Posted: Apr 17, 2007 10:21 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

hey jen! Definatly voted for photo album... Is so cute, and so nice to look back on. I really dont like the vase at all no offense!! The album just seems much more personal and would be a great keepsake. The vase can break and that'll be the end of that!

Kimbalina Posted: Apr 17, 2007 10:23 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

I think the vase is nice, but might be hard to handle or for some people to write on!

The album is so cute. I really like that idea!

LuvMyAlfonse Posted: Apr 17, 2007 10:29 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

OK ladies - I was leaning towards the vase but I didn't even consider the breakage aspect! Thanks girls! Photo album it is!

Super2star Posted: Apr 17, 2007 10:38 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

Posted by MrsBartonToBe

hey jen! Definatly voted for photo album... Is so cute, and so nice to look back on. I really dont like the vase at all no offense!! The album just seems much more personal and would be a great keepsake. The vase can break and that'll be the end of that!

I agree...I would be THAT girl to drop the vase...ahahaha

Belongs2DanBuckley Posted: Apr 17, 2007 11:07 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

DEF PHOTO ALBUM!!!!

cherish83 Posted: Apr 17, 2007 11:29 AM

Re: POLL: Guestbook - photo album from Shutterfly or Vase?

I'm torn between a guestbook or something different too.. If you think the vase would be to hard to sign, like Kim said, what about the serving platters. Thats what I like. But i dont think the photo guestbook would be narssistic