Prices for Rehearsal Dinners in Suffolk?

Since I am replanning some aspects of my wedding...I have to re-do the rehearsal dinner. Originally it was to be on a Thursday night and dinner at the Olive Garden. (Prices were great!)

Now the rehearsal is on Saturday afternoon, so I called the Olive Garden and they don't book tables on the weekends. Since my FI and I are paying for that and the wedding, we are really trying to keep costs down. Any suggestions? I did a search and found a few names that said 'reasonably priced' but what does that mean in $$ terms?

here are some I found, but haven't had a chance to call (i'm at work and it's long distance) Anyone have any idea of the prices?

Printer's Devil in Port Jeff
Mario's in East Setauket
John Harvards Lake Grove

Oh Yeah, it will be a Saturday Afternoon Luncheon not Dinner

I think that Printer's Devil won't do a party for less than 30 on a weekend and it was about $29.95/pp--? We ended up having ours at Desmond's at the Inn at East Wind. Very reasonably priced--I think it was $24.95pp.

I checked Danford's in Port Jeff also and it was close to $40pp.

Good luck!