Post New Topic

Question for Interfaith Brides

KandE917 Posted:

Re: Question for Interfaith Brides

Msgr. Lisante is AMAZING...you have nothing to worry about with him!!!

Are you getting married in a Catholic Church or does DH just want the marriage to be recognized by the Catholic Church?

I am Catholic and my DH is Jewish. We got married at our reception site but by both a priest and a rabbi. We went to Interfaith Precana but could have gone to non-interfaith...we just chose to do the interfaith one b/c we figured we'd get more out of it. We went to one at my high school - Kellenberg. It was really good and there was only a priest at pre-cana for a very short time to do prayers and talk a little. We didn't have much interaction with him. 2 couples ran pre-cana...one was a Catholic couple and one was interfaith. They were both so cool and open to everything and did not make anyone promise to raise their kids any certain way. You won't have to promise to do that...don't worry.
I being the Catholic did have to sign something saying I will do my best (but it does not make you swear or promise) to raise my children in the Catholic faith. DH did not have to sign anything like that though - just me.

Good luck with everything...FM me if you ever want to talk. Interfaith marriages can be tough b/c of all the family and the way they feel and stuff. I had a lot of crap to deal with when we were getting married and everyone is fine now...until we have kids of course and people ask 'baptism or bris?'...it's a personal thing and no one can tell you how to raise your children.

For your ceremony though make sure you stress the things you want and don't want.....our rabbi messed up big time. We asked for no hebrew to be spoken at all and he sang and chanted in hebrew for what felt like 10 minutes straight...we were dying. We asked him not to read straight from the ketubah and he did which took up so much time and cut into our picture taking time. He also did some other stuff that we asked him not too....we were really annoyed and unhappy with him. It sort of felt like he was competing with the priest - he tried to be funny a few times and was not - he was painful!
So just be sure to very specifically go over your ceremony with both your priest and rabbi!

Good luck!
nycgirl79 Posted:

Re: Question for Interfaith Brides


Posted by PreshusSmurf


Posted by nycgirl79

in the middle of their ceremony, in front of all our Jewish family, and the Rabbi, he sprung it on them. He basically told them during the ceremony that they must accept the teachings of Jesus and that they must raise their children the same way, or else they would be damned to hell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! As you can guess, we were all pretty horrified!




Hi Li!

Thanks for telling me this story!

The Priest we are meeting with is pretty well known for doing interfaith ceremonies, but I will definitely make it very clear not to include this as part of our ceremony.

I'm just gonna have to tell my Rabbi that if the Priest does this, he is to ask my FH if he promises to raise our children Jewish ... to accept the teachings of Moses or else, we would be damned and suffer ALL of the 10 plagues!!





OMG Jess!!! I LOVE it!! That's freaking perfect!!!

And I know your Priest isn't going to be anything like the other one - your ceremony is going to be beautiful! And btw, that's one more thing we have in common - we're both Jew girls!!!
MikeandJess Posted:

Re: Question for Interfaith Brides


Posted by nycgirl79

Hey Jess!

I don't mean to worry you, but PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make it 10000% clear to the Priest that you will not have that as a part of your ceremony (the raising your kids Catholic part). One of my second cousin's got married last September (she is Jewish, her now-dh is Catholic), and they made it very clear to the Priest, that they were going to raise their kids with an open mind to both religions. Evidently the Priest was 'ok' with it during their meetings, but in the middle of their ceremony, in front of all our Jewish family, and the Rabbi, he sprung it on them. He basically told them during the ceremony that they must accept the teachings of Jesus and that they must raise their children the same way, or else they would be damned to hell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! As you can guess, we were all pretty horrified!

I'm sure the Priest that you're meeting with is a reasonable (and respectful, considerate....) individual and will not put you through that, but I would just make it completely clear how you feel beforehand!!

Good luck with everything!!!



I don't mean to laugh but this sounds like a very terrible SNL skit, but old school SNL because I am picturing will farrell as the priest
PreshusSmurf Posted:

Re: Question for Interfaith Brides

I just wanted to thank everyone for helping me with this!!! All of your comments really helped to calm me before meeting with the Priest. I am so thankful that I have you ladies to help me navigate the wedding planning process!

The meeting went great. The Priest seriously couldn't have been a nicer person. FH & I are beyond thrilled!!!!
mbg1007 Posted:

Re: Question for Interfaith Brides


Posted by nycgirl79

Hey Jess!

I don't mean to worry you, but PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make it 10000% clear to the Priest that you will not have that as a part of your ceremony (the raising your kids Catholic part). One of my second cousin's got married last September (she is Jewish, her now-dh is Catholic), and they made it very clear to the Priest, that they were going to raise their kids with an open mind to both religions. Evidently the Priest was 'ok' with it during their meetings, but in the middle of their ceremony, in front of all our Jewish family, and the Rabbi, he sprung it on them. He basically told them during the ceremony that they must accept the teachings of Jesus and that they must raise their children the same way, or else they would be damned to hell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! As you can guess, we were all pretty horrified!

I'm sure the Priest that you're meeting with is a reasonable (and respectful, considerate....) individual and will not put you through that, but I would just make it completely clear how you feel beforehand!!

Good luck with everything!!!




I second that, my FBIL had an interfaith wedding with a priest and a rabbi and although it wasnt a part of the ceremony, he had to promise that he would raise the children catholic in order for his wife to get her marriage recognized (she told me this). Also I know of another interfaith wedding where the priest sprung the raising your kids catholic question during the ceremony without the couple knowing he was going to do so.
nycgirl79 Posted:

Re: Question for Interfaith Brides


Posted by PreshusSmurf

I just wanted to thank everyone for helping me with this!!! All of your comments really helped to calm me before meeting with the Priest. I am so thankful that I have you ladies to help me navigate the wedding planning process!

The meeting went great. The Priest seriously couldn't have been a nicer person. FH & I are beyond thrilled!!!!



That's awesome Jess! I'm so happy for you guys!!
prinses777 Posted:

Re: Question for Interfaith Brides

FH and I did NOT have to do Interfaith Pre Cana, I didn't even know this exsisted.

The Priest and people at PreCana new we lived together and nobody every said anything to us.

I guess its just who you get and on what....

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.