Post New Topic

RD dilemma

woobie113007 Posted:

RD dilemma

So FMIL wants to have the RD at her house. That would be all fine and well with me BUT they live in Bay Shore. The Church is in Bellmore. Now, I dont think it makes sense to have the RD in Bay Shore. I would say that 70% of the people are closest to Bellmore and then the other 30% are from Bay Shore. i dont think we should have the people that drove to bellmore drive even further out east to Bay Shore? Am I just over reacting?
So, I wanted to ask if you guys can recommed reasonably priced restaurants in the Bellmore, Wantagh, Seaford, Massapequa area for a RD.

Thanks!
KarinAmanda Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

DEFF try the Wantah Inn right near the Wantagh Train Station, on the same block as Mulcahys! Its a great restaurant and they have a private room perfect for a RD. Let me know if you need anymore details!!
KarinAmanda Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

Also, Knights of Columbus in Seaford is BEAUTIFUL ... Runyons on Merrick Rd. in Seaford, La Piazza in Bellmore on Merrick Rd.

LUCCA Italian restaraunt on Merrick Rd in Bellmore is great also.
KarinAmanda Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

I live in Seaford as if you couldnt tell
Jennifer907 Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

Sergio's in Massapequa on Merrick Rd, The Bulldog in Amityville on Montauk Hwy.

kitty1224 Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

Sergios in Massapequa is very reasonable

KarinAmanda Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

one more - Piccalos on Sunrise Hwy in Bellmore and also maybe Cafe Symposio

done, i promise
Fall07Bride Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

im getting married at st. barnabas and doing our's at Matteo's in Bellmore village. Its really nice and has a private room that holds up to 40 ppl. plus amazing prices!

here's the website:
http://www.matteosrestaurants.com/
kahlua716 Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

If your MIL is willing to host it, IMHO I wouldn't argue. Its not THAT far.

My church is in Massapequa and the RD will be in Deer Park.

I'm just grateful that she's doing SOMETHING...Maybe she can't afford to do it at a restaurant?


Good Luck! I'm sure everyone will enjoy themselves no matter whereit is


I just went back and read the whole post...oops. I thought you wanted suggestions on how to deal with her...

as for restaurant suggestions check out:

-Sergios (Massapequa)
-Bellissimo (Amityville)
-Katie Daylies (Massapequa)
-The Bulldog Cafe (Amityville)
donegal419 Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

I would check out the Wantagh Inn... I had mine there and it was GREAT! See my review...

Also, I would recommend:
Katie Dalys (massapequa)
Paddys Loft (massapequa)

Can you tell i know the Irish places
MalteseMommy Posted:

Re: RD dilemma


Posted by KarinAmanda

DEFF try the Wantah Inn right near the Wantagh Train Station, on the same block as Mulcahys! Its a great restaurant and they have a private room perfect for a RD. Let me know if you need anymore details!!



This is the place i was going to recommend as well. The food is awesome there!
MalteseMommy Posted:

Re: RD dilemma


Posted by KarinAmanda

DEFF try the Wantah Inn right near the Wantagh Train Station, on the same block as Mulcahys! Its a great restaurant and they have a private room perfect for a RD. Let me know if you need anymore details!!



Sorry! this posted twice!
Aug06 Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

We are having ours at the White Whale in Seaford. We wanted it to be very casual so everyone can mingle and they do a really nice buffet dinner. We are doing open bar as well and we got an amazing price, much cheaper than anywhere else we looked. It's pretty and right on the water.

jennd311 Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

we're doing ours at Matteos as well, the food is great and they have a nice room in the back so its private

Erica48 Posted:

Re: RD dilemma

I am also getting married at St Barnabas!!! We are having our RD at the wantagh inn in wantagh (we have a private room for a good price). Other places you can check out are piccolo's on sunrise highway in bellmore (that was our first choice but they were booked-its really close to the church) and you can also look into Viva Loca on merrick road in merrick, they have separate party rooms and its a fun place!

Reply to this topic

Log in to reply or quote a post.