Rehearsal Dinner near Port Jefferson

Hi!
Just wondering if anyone had any suggestions for Rehearsal Dinner places near the Port Jefferson area? The place I wanted to have it no longer is hosting private parties. It seems everywhere I have called is charging $40-60 per person, which seems like a lot to me. I guess because we are getting married off-season and our reception price isn't all that far from the upper end of the quotes I have been getting!
We have a large bridal party and immediate families, so the rehearsal dinner is going to be about 50 people.
Thanks for any suggestions!

Rehearsal Dinner near Port Jefferson

I'm thinking amici in mount Sinai but they told me they can only accommodate 40 or Lombardis on the sound.

Re: Rehearsal Dinner near Port Jefferson

im having my rehearsal dinner at attilios in st james, which is not far at all from port jeff. they can accomodate that number and are reasonably priced. they have 3 different options ranging from $25-30 pp.

also, my shower is on jan 20th at the fifth season in port jeff.. we invited about 65 people so they can def accomodate that many.

Rehearsal Dinner near Port Jefferson

Try danfords tequilla jacks, paces (delicious! Had my grad party there!) or I'd try aji in st James I'd your looking for Japanese!

Rehearsal Dinner near Port Jefferson

Danford's and paces are in the $45- 60 pricerange, I checked! Where is the church?

Rehearsal Dinner near Port Jefferson

Thanks for all the suggestions!
The church is Infant Jesus right in the village of Port Jefferson.