Rehearsal Dinner/ Port Jeff

I am looking for a different/ fun kind of place in Port Jeff for a RD. Not Italian food bc our RH has all Italian food. It's going to be on a Sat. night so some places won't book events. I looked at Papa Joe's shrimp and crab factory but their event menu has no seafood. Who wants penne vodka at a seafood place?

It doesn't have to be seafood---just thought that place was kind of different.

Any suggestions?
Defintely prefer something in/ very close to Port Jefferson.