shoe decision and poll - is this shoe good?

i can't decide if i should get a closed shoe or open shoe. since my dress is ivory and the shoes will be ivory, i will likely be able to wear the shoes again. so i'd like something that is not too 'bridey' for lack of a better term.

anyway, i think the open shoes would be more versatile, but also think that my dress calls for a closed shoe.

which should i do?

here is a pic of the dress.

how is this shoe? i've seriously been looking high and low and i think this one would be great. please help!!! i know i may seem obsessed but i'm a shoe freak, so the shoes are really important to me.