the jewelry store where he bought my current e-ring to look for bands. While we were there he told me to try on the same ering i have but with a bigger center stone . Now I think I love the bigger one. He's been asking which one I like better, what do you guys think? Should I egg on for the bigger one?
eta: upload pics since links didn't work. First one is one i want, second is one I have.
Honestly, maybe it's the photos but they don't look dramatically different to me. Therefore I'd go with the better quality stone.
Your ring is pretty though, I like the cut.
AngnShaun
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
it seems like an unneeded expense...
Golden
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
That's what FH said but then he keeps asking me what I really want...I think I'm just being spoiled. and a little bit of a brat...I love the one I have now though...thanks ladies!!!
JLWSJC
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Yeah, i fyou love your ring, then just leave it! That's the ring he asked you to marry him with! I'd be very sentimental about changing my diamond
MPascarella
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
I am very sentimental with things so I would keep the one that he proposed with. Your ring is beautiful though. I say splurge on the band Good Luck!!!
Mommy2BeBride
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
keep the one he proposed with.. thats the special part about the ring.. and since they both look so similar I would stay with the original!
mzmahagony
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Your ring looks like mine, I think they are both beutiful. Either way you go you can't loose. It's up to you which one you choose. If the price difference isn't that much then go for the bigger one. If it's a big differnce stay with the one you have. It's fab!
Diana12
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
I am very sentimental, so I would keep the ring that he proposed to me with
pipermaru
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Posted by Soon2BeMrsP
keep the one he proposed with.. thats the special part about the ring.. and since they both look so similar I would stay with the original!
i completely agree!
Golden
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Thanks guys
springsandra
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Your ring is beautiful!!!!! Tell him that he can get you lovely matching jewelry in the future, like maybe some stud earrings or something if he keeps offering. lol
Future Mrs P
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
I am super sentimental, so I would absolutely want to keep the one he proposed with. I really didn't see too much of a difference anyway, and the first one means so much more!!
JessNicole7EM
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Keep your ring. Tell him to take the extra money and buy you another piece of jewelery. :)
ourwedding9510
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Beautiful Ring!!! I don't see much of a difference but it might just be the pictures. I agree with the other girls. He proposed with the ring you have and that means more then a bigger stone. Put that money towards something else!
blessed18
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
splurge on the wedding band...i think the ring has too much sentimental value!!
MrsHazel2B
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
I wouldn't change the one he proposed with. FH did the same thing to me but I wouldn't have it. The one he proposed with is worth more to me than any clearer, larger stone. Keep the one you have, since it's already beautiful, and splurge on your wedding bands!
Im_My_Own_Princess
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Posted by MPascarella
I am very sentimental with things so I would keep the one that he proposed with. Your ring is beautiful though. I say splurge on the band Good Luck!!!
ITA agree with this... your ring is beautiful!
FH wants to get me a better quaility centerstone as a wedding gift, but I don't want one. THIS is the ring he proposed with... THIS is the one I said yes to.. I wouldn't change it for the world.
JMO...
MrsDR2010
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Posted by MPascarella
I am very sentimental with things so I would keep the one that he proposed with. Your ring is beautiful though. I say splurge on the band Good Luck!!!
ITA. I love ur ring.
BellaBride27
Posted:
Member since
Re: So FH took me to
Posted by Soon2BeMrsP
keep the one he proposed with.. thats the special part about the ring.. and since they both look so similar I would stay with the original!
