South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Original post by Fran M

Jul 08, 2003 11:56 AM

Help! I need a recommendation for a good not overly pricey Itialian restaurant in the Massapequa -Merrick area.

We plan on taking my MIL out Friday night. When she requested Italian we realized we havent tried any Itilian restaurants except for a few local pizza places.

Thanks as always

jenny2penny Posted: Jul 08, 2003 02:55 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

sergios always treated us well, and you can't beat the complete dinner price.

MarcellaBella Posted: Jul 08, 2003 02:56 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

try

Nick D'Angelo's
La Parma
Fabio's
Arthur Ave.
Elisa's

ThreeTwenty Posted: Jul 08, 2003 03:00 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

MMM...Nick D'angelos is GOOOOD!
La Parma is great too! I found a really small AWESOME place in hicksville called Venere-might be the best Italian restaurant around!

mlp924 Posted: Jul 08, 2003 03:17 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Matteo's on Bedford Avenue in Bellmore, Butera's in Massapequa by Stop and Shop or La Parma!

Jeanene Posted: Jul 08, 2003 03:37 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Can I make some more suggestions:

* Nick DeAngelo's on Sunrise Highway in Merrick

* Matteo's in Bellmore on Bellmore Avenue

* Villa la Pasta on Merrick Road in Bellmore

Good Luck!

Samanthas Mom Posted: Jul 09, 2003 09:30 AM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Lauren and I went to La Villa in massap last nite
it was very good!! and they were very nice too

endlessluv429 Posted: Jul 09, 2003 09:56 AM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Pamadorinos in Seaford on merrick rd is really nice and has great food/deals. there is amato's in amityville but that place has no windows if you get what i mean! LOL Great good but it's very dark in there! hahah i'm trying to think..sergios is good too..........

Samanthas Mom Posted: Jul 09, 2003 10:10 AM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

another vote for pomodorinos in seaford!

Claud2001 Posted: Jul 09, 2003 11:48 AM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Fran, we had Paul's christening and my grandmother's 80th b-day at Fabio's - food is delicious!

Also:
Matteo's
Elisa's
Nick D'Angelo's

Fran M Posted: Jul 09, 2003 12:45 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Thank you all so much! The restaurants with 4 or more votes each are:

La Parma
Nick D'Angelo's
Pomodorinos
Sergio's

Out of these 4 which do you think we have best shot at a table without a long wait on a Friday at 7:30ish? Are reservations a must at any of them?

Samanthas Mom Posted: Jul 09, 2003 01:20 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

I would call pomodorinos
they take reservations-- also last year I took DH there for b/day and I told the man that and he gave us a great table and everyone came and sang and they played happy birthday on their speakers

MSCJLK Posted: Jul 09, 2003 01:45 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Casa de paasta on Merrick road in Bellmore. Or Touge on Merrick road right before 7-11 ... it is really good. also Nick D angelo on Sunrise Hwy in merrikc is really good

princess99 Posted: Jul 09, 2003 01:49 PM

Re: South Shore Nassau C. Girls - Italian Rest Reco Please

Domenico's in Levittown is excellent, Fh and I went this week and it was not too crowded becuase it was a week night. Also, Arthur Ave. in East Meadow is good, or Vincent's in Carle Place is yummy.