Staten Island Rehearsal Dinner Location

My fiance's family is from Staten Island and since they are paying for the rehearsal dinner, they want it on Staten Island even though it is inconvenient for almost everyone and I feel like it's a gift with strings attached but anyway....

Does anyone know of some nice American or Italian restaurants on Staten Island for a rehearsal dinner for about 35 people?

Italianissimo
Nucci's
La Fontana
Marina Grand
Carmen's
Bistro
Villa

All are good places with the capacity for your size group.