What is America thinking? I am not happy with the last few vote offs. Just for the simple fact that there are people that are still on the show that really should not be. And Carly last nite-boo. I love her! Jason should have went before the last three that have been voted off!
bluegreen08
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
I figured the top 3 would be cook, archuleta and carly. Archuleta has a great voice but he's so boring and FH and I think he reminds us of an overprepped pageant kid.
I also think he looks like Oliver from the OC...
I always thought Syesha was one of the better girls in the competition, but I thought Carly would outlast her. Brooke should have gone home a long time ago when she sung Here Comes the Sun....
Dont know who the top 3 should be now... it would be hilarious if Jason made it but I think Syesha will take Carly's spot...
GinaZ
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by Sunset Renee
Posted by GinaZ
I thought for sure Carly would be in the top 3. She is friken amazing!!! I was so upset! I think I got teary eyed!!
Brook needs to go and so does Jason. Brook is talented but she just kinda bugs me cus she tries to act holier than now and its gotten old. And jason is good and Im sure has a devoted following, but his time is up. He will still prolly make an abum and do well. I want David Cook to win!!! David Archuletta is good, but he comes off very effected and not real to me.
I did cry - but I'm PMSing.....self explanatory!
LOL so was I!!!!! But I think I would have anyway! I felt so bad cus she is sooo good!
GinaZ
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by bluegreen08
I figured the top 3 would be cook, archuleta and carly. Archuleta has a great voice but he's so boring and FH and I think he reminds us of an overprepped pageant kid.
I also think he looks like Oliver from the OC...
I always thought Syesha was one of the better girls in the competition, but I thought Carly would outlast her. Brooke should have gone home a long time ago when she sung Here Comes the Sun....
Dont know who the top 3 should be now... it would be hilarious if Jason made it but I think Syesha will take Carly's spot...
OMG! me and my husband said the same thing about the pagent kid! And I said he looked like Oliver! To effin funny!!!! And I totally agree about Syesha and Carly. Carly is justa stronger mainstream performer/singer. Even though Syesha is awesome. God I hope brooke doesnt make top 3! Ugh!
TrueLoveIn2008
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
I don't watch the show - saw the 'recap' last few minutes of each performance show this week and last - but even I know they are making a mistake with who they are voting off. Sorry Heather, but I hate that Jason guy. His voice is very breathy. Carly is awesome. Brooke is ok, from what I get. David Cook is great, David A I think is terrible.
That's the opinion from the singer at heart who hates AI.
Toucan311
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by JBoothIn2008
I don't watch the show - saw the 'recap' last few minutes of each performance show this week and last - but even I know they are making a mistake with who they are voting off. Sorry Heather, but I hate that Jason guy. His voice is very breathy. Carly is awesome. Brooke is ok, from what I get. David Cook is great, David A I think is terrible.
That's the opinion from the singer at heart who hates AI.
WELL IM RIGHT AND YOU ARE WRONG. I AM THE QUEEN OF AMERICAN IDOL AND WHAT I SAY GOES. CARLY = UGLY TEETH, JASON = IN A WEIRD WAY REMINDS ME OF MY 13 YEAR OLD NEICE.
bluegreen08
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by JBoothIn2008
I don't watch the show - saw the 'recap' last few minutes of each performance show this week and last - but even I know they are making a mistake with who they are voting off. Sorry Heather, but I hate that Jason guy. His voice is very breathy. Carly is awesome. Brooke is ok, from what I get. David Cook is great, David A I think is terrible.
That's the opinion from the singer at heart who hates AI.
Jason is either great (like when he sung Hallelujah) or godawful (like this week) but he's hilarious to watch... he is so awkward and not fake that he's like the total opposite of David A. I'm always interested to see what he will do and if it will be good, but he's not in the same league as someone like David Cook.
David A actually has a great voice, he's just so annoying
I HATED BROOKE FROM WEEK ONE!!!!!! i was shocked she wasnt in the bottom this week. please america, send her home.
bluegreen08
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by GinaZ
Posted by bluegreen08
I figured the top 3 would be cook, archuleta and carly. Archuleta has a great voice but he's so boring and FH and I think he reminds us of an overprepped pageant kid.
I also think he looks like Oliver from the OC...
I always thought Syesha was one of the better girls in the competition, but I thought Carly would outlast her. Brooke should have gone home a long time ago when she sung Here Comes the Sun....
Dont know who the top 3 should be now... it would be hilarious if Jason made it but I think Syesha will take Carly's spot...
OMG! me and my husband said the same thing about the pagent kid! And I said he looked like Oliver! To effin funny!!!! And I totally agree about Syesha and Carly. Carly is justa stronger mainstream performer/singer. Even though Syesha is awesome. God I hope brooke doesnt make top 3! Ugh!
hahahaha thats so funny about the Oliver thing. Here are my other AI lookalikes, see any resemblance?
Brooke --- the annoying blind girl 'Amanda' from ANTM
Jason Castro -- John Travolta (his face, if you only look at his facial features) lol
David Cook -- his smile reminds me of the Joker from the old Batman movies
Carly -- she looks just like my friend who is getting married 2 weeks before us (who you obviously dont know) but it's pretty funny. her mannerisms are the same too. I posted a pic
I don't watch the show - saw the 'recap' last few minutes of each performance show this week and last - but even I know they are making a mistake with who they are voting off. Sorry Heather, but I hate that Jason guy. His voice is very breathy. Carly is awesome. Brooke is ok, from what I get. David Cook is great, David A I think is terrible.
That's the opinion from the singer at heart who hates AI.
WELL IM RIGHT AND YOU ARE WRONG. I AM THE QUEEN OF AMERICAN IDOL AND WHAT I SAY GOES. CARLY = UGLY TEETH, JASON = IN A WEIRD WAY REMINDS ME OF MY 13 YEAR OLD NEICE.
I think Jason looks kinda stoned every week!!! And poor Carly - too bad they dont do teeth with their makeovers!!
bluegreen08
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by Sunset Renee
I think Jason looks kinda stoned every week!!! And poor Carly - too bad they dont do teeth with their makeovers!!
Did you see his facial expression after his giant yawn last night? I really think he is stoned every night haha
Sunset Renee
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by bluegreen08
Posted by GinaZ
Posted by bluegreen08
I figured the top 3 would be cook, archuleta and carly. Archuleta has a great voice but he's so boring and FH and I think he reminds us of an overprepped pageant kid.
I also think he looks like Oliver from the OC...
I always thought Syesha was one of the better girls in the competition, but I thought Carly would outlast her. Brooke should have gone home a long time ago when she sung Here Comes the Sun....
Dont know who the top 3 should be now... it would be hilarious if Jason made it but I think Syesha will take Carly's spot...
OMG! me and my husband said the same thing about the pagent kid! And I said he looked like Oliver! To effin funny!!!! And I totally agree about Syesha and Carly. Carly is justa stronger mainstream performer/singer. Even though Syesha is awesome. God I hope brooke doesnt make top 3! Ugh!
hahahaha thats so funny about the Oliver thing. Here are my other AI lookalikes, see any resemblance?
Brooke --- the annoying blind girl 'Amanda' from ANTM
Jason Castro -- John Travolta (his face, if you only look at his facial features) lol
David Cook -- his smile reminds me of the Joker from the old Batman movies
Carly -- she looks just like my friend who is getting married 2 weeks before us (who you obviously dont know) but it's pretty funny. her mannerisms are the same too. I posted a pic
You weren't Kidding!!! Holy Moly!!!
Sunset Renee
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by bluegreen08
Posted by Sunset Renee
I think Jason looks kinda stoned every week!!! And poor Carly - too bad they dont do teeth with their makeovers!!
Did you see his facial expression after his giant yawn last night? I really think he is stoned every night haha
I really think he thinks it's a joke!! It's kinda funny - but kinda irritating at the same time! It is funny to watch him try to look normal when talking to the judges though - like he is always trying not to giggle - lol - STONER!!!
bumbumgirl
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by Sunset Renee
OMG!!!! I totally agree - I am so realy to boycott!!!! Or I should just start voting - It is one of the only things we can vote for where it actually counts - LMAO!!!! I want Jason and Brooke to go home!!! Carly is awesome - Why did she have to go??? What's next - David Cook in the Bottom Two??!?!?!?!?
Bite your tongue...David C in the bottom 2?!? NEVER! Would I like to see him win? I don't know because I would be worried that TPTB would change him into something he is not and he will fade into oblivion. I would like to see him make it to the final 2, and have the same successful career that Chris Daughtry has. (I can't believe I just said that...I was NOT a Chris D fan at all!)
I thought for sure that this was the week that Syesha was leaving, but I can't say that I am disappointed that Carly was the one sent packing. I didn't think she was all that great to begin with.
Am I the only one that doesn't get all the hype surrounding David A? He has a decent voice, but, to me, all I see is an annoying kid playing grown up.
David Cook is Awesome and should totally win!! He most def. has the most talent - David A - Bites the Big One - I do think he would do really well in like High School Musical or something Disney! Not a Pop-Star by a long shot!
bluegreen08
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by Sunset Renee
David Cook is Awesome and should totally win!! He most def. has the most talent - David A - Bites the Big One - I do think he would do really well in like High School Musical or something Disney! Not a Pop-Star by a long shot!
how long before he starts dating hanna montana or selena gomez? i can totally see him getting his own disney made for tv musical
hannahshim
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
i think Jason & Brooks should go!!!!
I didnt get to watch this weeks but OMG carley went home??????? shes like the best singer out of the girls.
I LOVE both the Davids~
I think they should be top 2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Butterfly123
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
I think you people are putting too much faith into the show. Do you really think our votes count??? Its almost like a real election.
Shelly9697
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
I want David Cook to win!!
bumbumgirl
Posted:
Member since
Re: Very disapointed with American Idol lately
Posted by Songstress
I think you people are putting too much faith into the show. Do you really think our votes count??? Its almost like a real election.
I don't put much faith in the show at all. I don't even vote because I don't think the votes count for anything at all. I watch for entertainment purposes only.
