I went to several well known reputable bagel stores to ask how much it would cost for an assortment of bagels with individual butters, jellies and cream cheeses. I'd like to use them as favors for my wedding. They ALL looked at me like I had two heads. Does anyone know where I can find a bagel store that accomodate me? I dont think Im asking for too much, but apparently I am!!
randella
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
I would also check out Zabars..
I believe you can even order online- how's that for convenience?
www.zabars.com
Jo Ann
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
How about doing it yourself. Go to a bagel store and get dozens of bagels and go to Costco and get the butter chips, cream cheese packets and jelly. You can get some nice gift bags and do it probally for a lot cheaper than some of these places are charging. Just make sure you order the bagels in advance and have ur bridal party put it all together for you.
DjPiLL
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
So you want to have a basket of bagels for everybody as a favor?
Thats a really cool idea.
The only thing you might want to think of... is if you throw some garlic and onion bagels in there... your hall might get a little smelly from the strong odor of garlic.
princess99
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
Bellmore Bagel Cafe in Bellmore. I used them for Yom Kippur break the fast. The also own 24 hour bagel in Oceanside. They were wonderful to work with and even called to make sure everyhting was to my satisfaction. Hope this helps.
BriBri529
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
Bagels and a Whole lot more in Stony Brook (I believe they have a New Hyde Park Location as well)
june262004
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
Posted by nov04LIbride
Bagel Boss is excellent! They are my favorite. It is a chain, but I go to the one in Bay Shore.
DITTO!!!
They ship all over Different states and everything.
june262004
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
I just saw u didn't like bagel boss. SO MY all time FAVORITE bagel place is
Bageltown of Levittown. Its on Hempstead tpke!
GroomsMom
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
Some caterers like Gabby's in Woodbury, Corinne's in Huntington, etc. have a mini bagel package that they do. Try Coliseum deli and caterers in Westbury, they are the best.
Nicki_Rini
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
GUESS WHAT!!!!!!!!!!! i work at a bagle shop!!!!!!!!!! lol but we suck at catering part, the bagles just come in a bag, and thats how we give it to the hilton and ups and all our other accounts but the bagles are reallly good but the sides are wayyyyy expensive, if u got the bagles from us, just buy the sides packaged, there not that expensive... where are u located??? we are in west babylon...
lillian771
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
Another vote for Gabby's. There are actually 2 of them on Jericho Tpk. in like a 3-mile radius. One is in Woodbury and the other Syosset. Good luck!
endlessluv429
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
My mom arranged with STUFF A BAGEL in Bethpage for the morning of the wedding! they're located in Bethpage and there's another one in Farmingdale I believe.
AJsMommy122
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
DUH this was your post!! Ok now I feel dumb
divabride
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
Thanks max, I forgot about all these possible leads. I'll check into them!
Blu-ize
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
I love Town Bagel. They are in Wantagh, Merrick and Plainview...they deliver, I don't know if they ship, but their stuff is great.
LilyOfValley
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
24 hour bagel, Oceanside..the best!
LaLa
Posted:
Member since
Re: Where can I get bagels catered?
A&S bagels in Franklin Square on Hempstead Tpke
I get them every time my school has a breakfast party. They are very reasonable and the bagels are the best!!!!!
